Former federal judges ask court to reopen Trump IRS case over settlement creating $1.776 billion fund
The facts
- A group of 35 former federal judges filed a motion asking a federal court in Florida to reopen the dismissed lawsuit between President Donald Trump and the IRS.
- The former judges said the court should investigate whether the out-of-court settlement amounted to fraud on the court because the settlement was not disclosed when the case was withdrawn.
- Trump, two of his adult sons and the Trump Organization had sued the IRS and Treasury Department over leaks of their tax information, and they voluntarily withdrew the case before it was dismissed with prejudice.
- After the case was withdrawn, the Justice Department announced a settlement that included creation of a $1.776 billion "Anti-Weaponization Fund."
- Multiple reports say the fund is intended to compensate people who claim they were targeted by the government for political or other improper reasons.
- The settlement has drawn broader scrutiny because it would direct a large sum of federal money through a new compensation program and includes terms related to IRS claims involving Trump.
- U.S. District Judge Kathleen Williams dismissed the case after the plaintiffs withdrew it, noting that the filings did not reference a settlement and that no settlement documents were submitted to the court.
- The former judges’ filing is the latest legal challenge to the settlement, and whether the case will be reopened now depends on how the court responds to their motion.
Context
What was the original lawsuit about?
The lawsuit was brought by Trump, two of his adult sons and the Trump Organization against the IRS and Treasury Department over leaks of their tax information by a former IRS employee or contractor in 2019 and 2020 CNBC,News International,Rolling Out.
Why do the former judges want the case reopened?
They argue the parties withdrew the case without telling the court about a planned settlement and want the judge to examine whether that omission improperly misled the court Aol,USA Today,Court House News Se….
Common ground, and where they split
- Common ground
- A settlement announced only after the case was withdrawn created a $1.776 billion compensation fund and now faces a serious court-focused challenge over whether keeping it out of the filings misled the judge who dismissed the suit.
- Where Left and Right split
- Less a disagreement than a question of emphasis: the unusual scale and public-money design of the new compensation fund, versus the narrower procedural question of whether an undisclosed settlement improperly bypassed the court when the case was withdrawn.
How left and right read it
What stands out here is the combination of secrecy and scale: former federal judges are asking the court to examine whether an undisclosed settlement accompanied the withdrawal of a case that later produced a large new compensation fund. That matters because the settlement has drawn scrutiny over directing substantial federal money through a new program and because it includes terms related to IRS claims involving Trump.
The key issue is whether the court was kept in the dark when the case was withdrawn and dismissed with prejudice, even though a settlement was later announced. That matters because former federal judges are asking the court to determine whether the undisclosed settlement amounted to fraud on the court, and the next step depends on how the court responds to that motion.
The receipts — 20 sources
Other coverage (20)
A news briefing built to show both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.