Appeals Court Orders Narrower LinkedIn Data Request in Leak Investigation
The facts
- The Fourth Circuit ordered a lower court to narrow LinkedIn’s required disclosure of journalists’ records.
- The Justice Department sought LinkedIn records as part of a leak investigation.
- The appeals court found the government’s requested records were overly broad.
- The requested records could reveal confidential sources unrelated to the leak investigation.
- The case concerns reporters whose employer was not identified in court records.
- The ruling left open the possibility that the government may obtain a narrower set of records.
Context
What did the appeals court decide?
The court held that the lower court’s disclosure order was too broad and directed it to draw a narrower order for any LinkedIn records sought in the leak investigation. U.S. News & World R… Court House News Se… unb.com.bd
Why did the court require a narrower request?
The panel said broad access to journalists’ records could expose confidential sources with no connection to the investigation and impair press freedom. NYT POLITICO U.S. News & World R…
Does the decision end the leak investigation?
No. The ruling did not eliminate the government’s ability to pursue records; it required the lower court to limit the scope of any disclosure order. Hill Washington Sun unb.com.bd
Common ground, and where they split
- Common ground
- The appeals court found the government's records request overly broad, and both sides accept a narrower request could still be obtained.
- Where Left and Right split
- The left and the right agree the request was too broad but differ on what the ruling proves.
- Why they differ
- The two sides divide on institutional trust: one treats courts as the needed check forcing government to justify each record it seeks, the other treats the same ruling as leaving investigative authority essentially intact.
How left and right read it
A leak investigation does not entitle the government to sweep up records that could expose confidential sources unrelated to the inquiry, so the burden belongs on the government to narrow its demand first. That is why the finding that the request was overly broad matters, even though a tailored request remains possible. Source protection has to be the default, not an afterthought weighed against investigative convenience.
“The battle over the reporters' data adds to the Trump administration's increasingly aggressive efforts to investigate leaks and threaten reporters.” — The New York Times
When a leak investigation is underway, the real stake is whether the government can still obtain the records it needs, not whether it can demand everything at once. The appeals court objected to the breadth of what was sought, leaving open the chance for a narrower set of records to be obtained. A ruling against overbreadth is not a ruling against pursuing leaks, and that distinction should hold.
The ruling draws a line: the government can't sweep up unrelated sources, but a tailored request can still reach the leak.
The receipts — 15 sources
Wire services (4)
Other coverage (11)
A news briefing built to show both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.