BBC asks Florida court for permission to subpoena Trump's two eldest children and son-in-law
The facts
- The BBC filed a motion Friday asking a Florida federal court to authorise subpoenas for Donald Trump Jr., Ivanka Trump and Jared Kushner.
- The subpoenas seek both deposition testimony and documents relating to the events of 6 January 2021.
- President Trump is seeking $10bn in damages over a 2024 BBC Panorama documentary that spliced together separate portions of his 6 January speech.
- Trump filed the lawsuit in Florida in December 2025, accusing the BBC of "intentionally, maliciously and deceptively doctoring" the speech.
- BBC lawyers wrote that the three relatives "without question have personal knowledge" of Trump's intentions in delivering the speech.
- The filing cites House January 6 committee evidence that Trump Jr. and Ivanka Trump were present when their father revised and delivered the speech.
- The filing says Kushner drafted a proposed statement for Trump that would have condemned the use of violence.
- The BBC has apologised for the edit, which it called an "error of judgment", but denies it constitutes grounds for defamation.
- Repeated attempts to serve the subpoenas by hand in May were unsuccessful, and police blocked BBC representatives at Ivanka Trump and Kushner's Miami home.
- The BBC has separately asked the court to dismiss the lawsuit entirely.
Context
Why does the BBC want testimony from Trump's relatives?
BBC lawyers argue they are entitled to examine Trump's "intention behind the speech and anything that bears on the impression his audience could have reasonably obtained in listening to the speech" Guardian,Yahoo. They say the three relatives have firsthand knowledge and likely hold relevant records, because Trump Jr. and Ivanka Trump were present during the speech's revision and delivery and Kushner drafted a statement condemning violence BBC,Hill,Business Standard.
What is the BBC asking the court to do about service?
Because hand delivery failed, the BBC asked the judge to authorise alternative methods of service, including email and certified mail BBC,Washington Examiner. Court filings describe attempts in May, one of which ended with BBC representatives being turned away by police outside Ivanka Trump and Kushner's Miami residence Raw Story,Daily Beast,DNyuz.
What is the BBC's defence in the underlying case?
The BBC acknowledges the footage was edited and has apologised, saying the programme gave "the impression of a direct call for violent action", but it disputes that this meets the legal criteria for defamation Kent Online,Washington Examiner,VANNY RADIO. It has also argued the documentary was not made available on its US platforms and has asked the court to dismiss the suit VANNY RADIO,GB News.
Common ground, and where they split
- Common ground
- The BBC's concession that the splice was an error of judgment is treated as genuine by both reads, and both accept that discovery must be measured against what the claim actually requires.
- Where Left and Right split
- A sitting president wielding a $10bn claim against a broadcaster and facing ordinary discovery, or a defense reaching past the edit into three relatives' lives.
How left and right read it
A $10bn defamation claim brought by a sitting president against a public broadcaster is an exercise of raw power over the press, and it should be tested with the same discovery any other litigant would face. That is why the request for testimony matters: the relatives said to have been present when the 6 January speech was revised and delivered, and the one who drafted a statement condemning violence, hold knowledge of intent. The BBC already called the edit an error of judgment. Accountability has to run both ways.
“The BBC is trying to subpoena Donald Trump's children as it builds its defense against the president's defamation lawsuit centered on a documentary on the January 6 insurrection.” — The Guardian
Discovery is supposed to test the claim actually at issue, and the claim here is about a 2024 Panorama edit that spliced separate portions of the 6 January speech — an edit the broadcaster itself has already called an error of judgment. That concession narrows the ground. Yet the defense reaches past the edit, seeking depositions and documents from the president's son, daughter and son-in-law. Where does a family's exposure end?
“The BBC is trying to subpoena Donald Trump's children as part of the president's $10bn (£7.4bn) defamation battle with the broadcaster.” — The Telegraph
The receipts — 22 sources
Other coverage (22)
A news briefing built to show both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.