Study Estimates Carbon Emissions From 403 Large U.S. Data Centers
|
The facts
- A Harvard-led study examined 403 large U.S. data centers from May 2024 through April 2025.
- The study was published in the journal Nature Sustainability.
- The 403 data centers were associated with an estimated 25.7 million metric tons of carbon dioxide emissions.
- The study estimated the facilities used about 1.8% of total U.S. electricity consumption.
- The facilities used an estimated 68 to 99 terawatt-hours of electricity during the study period.
- Fossil fuels supplied 54% of the electricity supporting the data centers.
- The estimated emissions were two to three times the 2018 estimate for U.S. data centers.
- The study covers 403 facilities, while reports say about 1,200 such facilities operate in the United States.
Context
What kinds of facilities did the study examine?
It examined hyperscale data centers, large facilities used for cloud computing and AI-related workloads, including training large language models and delivering AI tools. infobae SAPO
How do the estimated emissions compare internationally?
Multiple reports compared the 25.7 million metric tons of estimated annual carbon dioxide emissions with Denmark's annual emissions; other reports also compared them with Bolivia's. U.S. News & World R… El HuffPost
What does the study leave unresolved?
The estimate covers 403 facilities rather than all U.S. hyperscale data centers; reports cite about 1,200 operating facilities and additional projects. BFMTV SudOuest.fr Jakarta Globe
Common ground, and where they split
- Common ground
- The 403 measured data centers emitted two to three times 2018 estimates while running 54% on fossil fuels, and both framings treat that sample as incomplete against roughly 1,200 facilities nationwide.
- Where Left and Right split
- The left and the right split on whether thin data justifies mandates now or demands more measurement first.
- Why they differ
- The disagreement is about trust: whether an industry that operated under secrecy must now prove its grid impact safe, or whether skeptics must justify forcing costly fixes on an unproven snapshot.
How left and right read it
Precaution, not trust, should govern how much fossil-fueled power feeds the computing boom, when 403 data centers ran 54% on fossil fuels and emitted two to three times the 2018 estimate, a fraction of the roughly 1,200 facilities reported nationwide. As the New York Times noted, uncovering that required work showing 'the secrecy under which A.I. companies have been allowed to operate' — opacity that clean-energy standards should no longer allow.
“Much of the analysis in the study amounted to detective work, underscoring the secrecy under which A.I. companies have been allowed to operate.” — The New York Times
Before sweeping mandates reshape how computing is powered, the burden of proof should fall on those demanding them, not on an industry still being measured, since the study covers only 403 of the roughly 1,200 such facilities now operating nationwide. Fossil fuels supplying 54% of that power reflects the grid as it currently exists, not a failure demanding punitive new costs.
The 403 measured centers run mostly on fossil power. The fight is whether that data justifies mandates or means we need more measurement.
The receipts — 88 sources
Wire services (2)
Other coverage (86)
A news briefing built to show both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.