Justice B.V. Nagarathna says Centre should treat states as co-equals in constitutional federalism
The facts
- Justice B.V. Nagarathna delivered the Rajendra Prasad Memorial Lecture at Chanakya Law University/Chanakya National Law University in Patna.
- Justice Nagarathna said the Centre should view states as co-equal or coordinate units rather than as subordinates.
- She said India’s constitutional structure creates a balance of powers between the Centre and states rather than a hierarchy.
- Justice Nagarathna called for greater coordination and dialogue between the Union and state governments in handling federal relations.
- She said political or inter-party differences between governments at the Centre and in states should be kept aside in Centre-state relations.
- Justice Nagarathna warned that increasing conflict between the Centre and states or among states harms constitutional governance.
- In the same lecture, she said institutions such as the Election Commission must function independently and not be influenced by political processes.
Context
What was Justice Nagarathna’s main point about federalism?
She said federalism is not a hierarchy in which the Centre commands the states; instead, it is a constitutional arrangement of co-equals that requires negotiation, coordination and mutual respect between distinct centres of power Hindustan Times,New Indian Express,ThePrint.
Why did she say Centre-state clashes matter?
She said rising disputes between the Centre and states, or among states, weaken the constitutional form of governance and should be avoided through dialogue and negotiation rather than treating each other as courtroom adversaries Hindustan Times,Times of India.
What did she say about the Election Commission?
Justice Nagarathna said the Election Commission’s independence is essential because if those conducting elections depend on those contesting them, the neutrality of the electoral process cannot be assured Indian Express,Tribune,ETV Bharat News,NewsDrum.
The receipts — 17 sources
Other coverage (17)
A news briefing built to show both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.