France- and Netherlands-led operation dismantles First VPN service linked to cybercrime
The facts
- Authorities said First VPN was dismantled in an international law-enforcement operation led by France and the Netherlands, with support from Europol and Eurojust.
- The operation took place on May 19 and 20, and authorities said 33 servers were seized in multiple European countries.
- French prosecutors said First VPN was widely used by cybercriminals to hide their identity or the origin of their online activity.
- Multiple reports said the service was advertised on Russian-speaking cybercrime forums.
- French authorities said their investigation began in December 2021 after repeated use of the service was found in offenses harming French victims.
- Authorities said the main administrator, located in Ukraine, was questioned there at the request of the French investigating judge.
- Europol said First VPN featured in many major cybercrime investigations it supported in recent years, indicating the takedown could aid broader ongoing cases beyond this single service.
- Some reports said investigators identified users of the service after the operation, but the scope of those identifications and any resulting charges were not detailed in the source pool.
Context
What was First VPN accused of doing?
Authorities said it provided a way to reroute internet connections through third-party servers so users could avoid identification, and that cybercriminals used it to conceal activity linked to ransomware, data theft, fraud and other offenses SudOuest.fr,Straits Times,Computer Weekly.
Why were French authorities involved?
Paris prosecutors said they opened an investigation in December 2021 after repeatedly seeing the service used in crimes that harmed French victims, which led to the Franco-Dutch judicial operation announced this week Franceinfo,SudOuest.fr.
What is still unclear after the takedown?
The sources indicate that users were identified and the main administrator in Ukraine was questioned, but they do not consistently establish how many people were identified, whether arrests were made beyond that questioning, or what charges may follow Tom's Guide,7sur7,Actu17 - Actualité ….
Common ground, and where they split
- Common ground
- A cross-border takedown of a service authorities said was repeatedly used to conceal cybercrime is a legitimate law-enforcement response, with consequences likely extending beyond one VPN because the service appeared across multiple major investigations.
- Where Left and Right split
- Less a disagreement than a question of emphasis: protecting the public by disrupting criminal infrastructure used across cases, versus stressing a narrowly targeted action against alleged misuse rather than online privacy tools in general.
How left and right read it
What matters most here is collective protection: French authorities said the service was repeatedly used in offenses harming French victims, and Europol said it appeared in many major cybercrime investigations it supported. On that view, coordinated action against infrastructure authorities say helped conceal online activity is about protecting the public and strengthening institutions’ ability to respond across cases, not just closing one service.
What stands out is a bounded law-enforcement action aimed at a service authorities said was used to hide identity and online activity, rather than a broader move against online privacy tools in general. The emphasis is on targeted investigation, questioning the main administrator at the request of a French investigating judge, and possible follow-on cases tied to identified users, which speaks to individual responsibility and procedural restraint.
The receipts — 44 sources
Wire services (1)
Other coverage (43)
A news briefing built to show both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.