Skip to content
ReframedNewsLeft · Right · Centered
Quick ReadArchiveAboutSign in
Briefing stories›U.S. Politics

Jack Smith defends Trump prosecutions at Senate Judiciary Committee hearing

Story date · Tuesday, September 29, 2026The United StatesU.S. PoliticsWell-covered
  
 
 
 
 
           
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
PROSECUTOR TESTIFIES BEFORE THE SENATEREFRAMED ILLUSTRATION

The facts

  • Jack Smith testified before the Senate Judiciary Committee about his investigations of Donald Trump.
  • Smith defended his decision to bring criminal charges against Trump.
  • Smith said his charging decisions were made without regard to Trump’s political affiliation or candidacy.
  • Republican lawmakers accused Smith of abusing his authority in the Trump investigations.
  • Smith’s cases concerned Trump’s efforts to overturn the 2020 election results and classified documents kept at Mar-a-Lago.
  • The two federal criminal cases against Trump were dismissed before trial.
  • Smith said he would not be silenced by threats of prosecution.

Context

What cases did Smith bring against Trump?

Smith brought federal cases concerning Trump’s alleged efforts to overturn the 2020 election and his retention of classified documents at Mar-a-Lago after leaving office. infobae Washington Post Al Jazeera Online CNN

What did Smith say in response to Republican accusations?

Smith said the charging decisions were driven by evidence, not Trump’s political identity, and said he stood by his decisions as special counsel. Aol CBS News Al Jazeera Online U.S. News & World R…

What became of the federal cases against Trump?

Both federal cases were dismissed before trial. NBC News HuffPost CNN

Common ground, and where they split

Common ground
Both cases collapsed before trial, meaning neither Trump's alleged conduct nor Smith's charging theory was ever tested before a jury.
Where Left and Right split
Trump facing accountability for conduct ordinary defendants would answer for, or a prosecutor's surveillance reach sweeping up journalists and sources.
Why they differ
The divide is trust-in-institution: whether Smith's prosecutorial discretion and surveillance methods deserve deference or suspicion doesn't hinge on the dismissed cases' facts but on priors about DOJ independence from politics.
Watch for
Whether Grassley's committee substantiates or the whistleblower disclosures are corroborated that nearly 50 journalists' communications were swept into Smith's 'Arctic Frost' digital dragnet would test the surveillance claims driving the right's accountability push.New York Post

How left and right read it

Left says

No one should be safer from the criminal law because they were on a ballot, and that is precisely the principle Smith defended when he said his charging decisions ignored Trump's party and candidacy. The conduct at issue — attempting to overturn the 2020 results, classified documents held at Mar-a-Lago — is the kind ordinary defendants answer for, yet both cases died before any jury weighed them. So the hearing turned on gotchas and basketball trivia rather than evidence. Smith said threats of prosecution will not silence him. They shouldn't.

“Sen. Eric Schmitt thought he caught Jack Smith in a lie. Instead, he outed him as a fan of former Iowa Hawkeyes star Caitlin Clark.” — POLITICO↗

Right says

A prosecutor's reach should be measured by whom it sweeps up, not only by whom it charges, which is why disclosures to the committee's chairman about journalists' messages with government sources landing in Smith's digital dragnet matter more than his insistence that party played no part in his decisions. Both cases died before trial. So the charging theory was never tested, yet the surveillance was real — and Congress should press the accountability that testimony alone cannot deliver.

“The Senate Judiciary Committee chairman's office received whistleblower disclosures that revealed almost 50 journalists had their messages with government sources caught in Smith's digital dragnet.” — New York Post↗

See this differently than someone you know would?

The receipts — 100 sources

Wire services (12)

ReutersReuters'I will not be silenced,' says Jack Smith on Trump prosecuti...
APWTOPSupreme Court lets Trump continue deporting people to third ...
APEast Idaho NewsEx-special counsel Smith tells senators he won't 'be silence...
ReutersYahoo!Exfiscal que investigó a Trump dice al Senado que no será "s...
APThe Dallas Morning NewsEx-special counsel Smith tells senators he won't 'be silence...
APDaily NewsWatch live: Ex-Trump prosecutor Smith will tell senators he ...
APMy NorthwestEx-Trump prosecutor Smith will tell senators he won't 'be si...
APSunSentinelEx-special counsel Smith tells senators he won't 'be silence...
APTribLIVEEx-Trump prosecutor Jack Smith forcefully defends investigat...
APU.S. News & World ReportEx-Trump Prosecutor Smith Will Tell Senators He Won't 'Be Si...
ReutersReutersFormer Trump prosecutor Jack Smith faces Senate hearing over...
APTribLIVESenators gear up for Judiciary clash with Jack Smith

Other coverage (88)

ArkansasOnlineEx-prosecutor defends probes of Trump | Arkansas Democrat Ga...
International Business Times UK'Perhaps You Should Have Looked More Carefully': Jack Smith ...
International Business Times UKSenator Kennedy Says Jack Smith Makes Him 'Want to Throw Up'...
WION'President Trump engaged in serious crimes against our natio...
France 24Jack Smith, exfiscal especial, responde al Senado y reafirma...
Al Jazeera OnlineJack Smith defends investigations into Trump during tense US...
PBS.orgDuring Senate hearing, Jack Smith defends criminal investiga...
The Daily SignalJack Smith Scooped Up Reporters' Phone Data in Trump Probe: ...
Crooks and LiarsJack Smith: Trump Engaged In Crimes Against Our Nation
CNN EspañolUn momento incómodo para el Partido Republicano, un testigo ...
YahooRepublicans wanted Jack Smith to give them a smoking gun. Th...
TelemundoEn una audiencia del Senado marcada por insultos republicano...
The HillSmith fields GOP insults, questions on lawmaker subpoenas at...
YahooSmith fields GOP insults, questions on lawmaker subpoenas at...
TownhallJack Smith's Defense As an Unbiased Prosecutor Got Obliterat...
Washington ExaminerJack Smith dodges questions about spying on Republican lawma...
The Irish TimesFormer Trump prosecutor Jack Smith tells US Senate he will n...
Washington ExaminerHawley calls for Jack Smith to be disbarred during Senate he...
The Philadelphia InquirerJack Smith clashes with senators over Trump probes, says he ...
New York PostJack Smith's team got texts of dozens of reporters, bank inf...
Economic Times'I will not be silenced': Ex-Trump prosecutor Jack Smith sta...
news24Former prosecutor slams threats, erosion of rule of law unde...
Houston ChronicleTed Cruz accuses Jack Smith, who charged Trump, of 'egregiou...
ABC7 New YorkEx-special counsel Jack Smith tells Senate panel 'I stand by...
WNDWATCH: Jack Smith collected nearly 5,000 personal checks of ...
Honolulu Star AdvertiserJack Smith defends Trump investigations during heated Senate...
EL PAÍSNo seré silenciado por las amenazas del presidente": Jack Sm...
The Globe and MailFormer trump prosecutor defends investigations as Republican...
The New Indian ExpressEx-Trump prosecutor Smith forcefully defends investigations ...
Roll CallJack Smith pressed on DOJ probes -- and basketball
Deseret NewsMike Lee grills former DOJ special counsel who seized his ph...
Alternet.orgLegal experts expose the glaring hole in GOP attacks on Jack...
The HillJack Smith spars with GOP senators
YahooFormer prosecutor slams threats, erosion of rule of law unde...
One America News NetworkFmr Special Counsel Jack Smith faces scrutiny from GOP lawma...
El UniversalExfiscal Jack Smith defiende cargos contra Trump por comicio...
Los Angeles TimesEx-special counsel Smith tells senators he won't 'be silence...
CTPostThe Latest: Trump's new AI-powered 'America.gov' pivots poli...
UPIJack Smith speaks to Senate Judiciary Committe about prosecu...
The News InternationalEx-special counsel says he would prosecute Trump again based...
AolEx-special counsel Jack Smith tells lawmakers 'I stand by' d...
Bloomberg BusinessEx-Trump Prosecutor Spars With GOP Senators, Defends Probe S...
The Daily CallerThanks To Jack Smith, FBI Has Financial Data On Thousands Of...
Conservative News TodayJack Smith collected banking information on thousands of tru...
el Nuevo HeraldEx fiscal defiende ante Senado los casos contra Trump por co...
TimesNowJack Smith Says Investigation Proved 'Beyond Reasonable Doub...
NewsweekKennedy spars with Jack Smith during tense Senate testimony
Raw Story'Elder abuse': Experts alarmed by Chuck Grassley 'ranting wi...
abc15 ArizonaSenate Republicans target former special counsel Jack Smith ...
El EconomistaExfiscal que investigó a Trump dice al Senado que no será "s...
International Business Times UKJack Smith Says He Had 'Proof Beyond a Reasonable Doubt' Aga...
infobaeExfiscal defiende ante Senado los casos contra Trump por com...
ABC DigitalExfiscal defiende ante el Senado los casos contra Trump por ...
El Diario Nueva YorkJack Smith sobre Trump en audiencia ante el Senado: "Cometió...
Raw StoryJack Smith cracks down as MAGA senator attacks wife: 'Not go...
The Daily WireWATCH LIVE: Disgraced Jack Smith Faces Lion's Den Over Trump...
PBS.orgWATCH: Jack Smith says he would prosecute Trump again for 's...
MediaiteJack Smith: Trump 'Engaged in Serious Crimes' Against US
Washington PostJack Smith clashes with senators over Trump probes, says 'I ...
The Spokesman ReviewJack Smith clashes with senators over Trump probes, says he ...
New York PostEx-special counsel Jack Smith accused of 'corrupt' probe of ...
Washington ExaminerWATCH LIVE: Jack Smith testifies before the Senate Judiciary...
The Daily BeastJack Smith's Message for Trump Revealed Before Senate Showdo...
RedstateJack Smith Says That If He Had to Do It All Over, He Would P...
AolJack Smith stresses strength of Trump cases, says he will no...
RedstateJack Smith Crossed the Line: 87 White House Phones and Major...
LBCFormer Trump prosecutor Jack Smith faces Senate hearing over...
The HillWatch live: Jack Smith testifies before Senate panel on Trum...
CNNLive updates: Jack Smith testifies before the Senate Judicia...
The Detroit NewsFormer Trump prosecutor Jack Smith tells Senate he won't be ...
Alternet.orgJim Jordan 'will fail miserably': Legal expert wrecks GOP's ...
The HillJack Smith stresses strength of Trump cases, says he will no...
POLITICOWhat Jack Smith plans to tell the Senate Judiciary Committee
NewsdayEx-Trump prosecutor Smith forcefully defends investigations ...
CBS NewsJack Smith, ex-special counsel, to testify about Trump probe...
YahooJack Smith defends Trump probes in Senate hearing filled wit...
NBC NewsSenate GOP to press Jack Smith on Trump Jan. 6 probe as DOJ ...
POLITICOInside Congress Live
Fox NewsJack Smith grilled by Senate Judiciary Committee over Trump ...
Fox NewsJack Smith probe swept up Fox News, other media communicatio...
www.theepochtimes.comJack Smith Says Obtaining Lawmakers' Phone Records Was 'Cent...
The New RepublicJack Smith Found Proof Beyond "Reasonable Doubt" of Trump's ...
ArcaMaxJack Smith pressed on DOJ probes -- and basketball
Breaking News.ieFormer Trump prosecutor Jack Smith tells US Senate he will n...
PBS.orgWATCH LIVE: Jack Smith testifies before Senate Judiciary as ...
Roll CallSenators gear up for Judiciary clash with Jack Smith
HuffPostInvestigators Probing 'New Possible Ransom Note' In Nancy Gu...
ArcaMaxSenators gear up for Judiciary clash with Jack Smith

A news briefing built to show both sides.

The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.

← Earlier in this briefing
U.S.-Led Coalition Ends Military Mission in Iraq
U.S. forces and the U.S.-led coalition have completed their withdrawal from Iraq, ending the anti-Islamic State mission...
U.S. Politics
Next in this briefing →
Russian envoy meets U.S. officials in Washington on Ukraine and energy initiativ...
Russian presidential envoy Kirill Dmitriev met U.S. officials in Washington to discuss a peaceful resolution of the war...
International Affairs

Continue Reading

More in U.S. Politics

Trump denies offering Iran sanctions relief for nuclear concessions

President Donald Trump denied reports that he was prepared to offer Iran sanctions relief and release frozen funds in...

U.S. Politics
Related this week

Report: Mossad shared warning with CIA about possible Iranian drone attacks on Trump

Israel Hayom reported that Mossad shared intelligence with the CIA alleging that Iran could target President Donald...

International Affairs
From this briefing

Supreme Court Temporarily Allows Third-Country Deportations

The Supreme Court temporarily allowed the Trump administration to resume deporting some migrants to countries other...

Rights & Justice
Back to all stories

A news briefing built to show both sides.

The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.

ReframedNews

A daily news briefing on the day’s top stories, built to show both sides.

Written by AI from news reporting. We review published briefings. Who writes this →

Navigate

Quick ReadArchiveSettings

Company

AboutHow it worksSkylark CreationsSign InTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

© 2026 Reframed.News

Made by Skylark Creations