Gujarat High Court issues AI policy barring its use in judicial decision-making and judgment drafting
The facts
- The Gujarat High Court issued a policy on the use of artificial intelligence in judicial and court administration.
- The policy prohibits AI from being used for judicial decision-making, adjudication, or judicial reasoning.
- The policy bars AI from drafting or preparing judgments and orders.
- The policy says AI should not be used for bail or sentencing considerations or other substantive adjudicatory processes.
- The policy allows limited AI use for administrative or research-related tasks, subject to human oversight.
- The policy cites risks from AI including hallucinations, bias, confidentiality breaches, and erosion of judicial independence.
- The policy applies to judicial officers and court staff in the High Court and district judiciary in Gujarat.
- The policy holds judges responsible for orders and judgments issued in their names.
Context
What kinds of AI use are prohibited under the policy?
The policy bars AI from judicial decision-making and reasoning, drafting judgments or orders, evaluating evidence, and handling bail, sentencing, or other substantive adjudicatory functions Hindustan Times,Hindu,Times of India.
What AI uses are still allowed?
The High Court allows limited AI use for support functions such as legal research, translation, grammar checks, cause-list management, and some administrative tasks, provided there is human oversight Indian Express,ETV Bharat News.
Why did the court say limits on AI were necessary?
The policy says AI tools pose risks including hallucinations, bias, confidentiality breaches, and erosion of judicial independence, so they must not replace human judicial reasoning Economic Times,New Indian Express,NewsDrum.
The receipts — 18 sources
Other coverage (18)
A news briefing built to show both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.