Appeals court stays enforcement of Sabah 40% revenue review order pending federal appeal
The facts
- The Court of Appeal allowed the federal government's application for a stay of execution on the High Court order concerning Sabah's 40% revenue entitlement pending appeal.
- The appellate court said the federal government would be prejudiced if forced to comply with the High Court order before its appeal is heard.
- The High Court order had imposed timelines requiring a review within 90 days and an agreement within 180 days.
- The stay pauses the High Court's timelines and related payment obligations while the appeal is pending.
- Sabah Chief Minister Hajiji Noor said the state government respects the Court of Appeal's decision and described the stay as procedural in nature that keeps the status quo until the appeal is heard.
- Hajiji Noor said he hopes negotiations with the federal government will continue in good faith despite the court proceedings.
- The Sabah Law Society said the stay order is procedural and does not displace the High Court's findings, with the substantive constitutional issues remaining to be decided on appeal.
- The federal government said its appeal does not challenge Sabah's 40% entitlement formula itself, but concerns parts of the High Court ruling and its implementation.
Context
What does the stay order do?
It temporarily suspends enforcement of the High Court order while the federal government's appeal is heard, including the court-imposed timelines for review, agreement and payment Malay Mail,Free Malaysia Today,星洲日报.
Does the stay mean the High Court ruling was overturned?
No. Sabah Chief Minister Hajiji Noor and the Sabah Law Society said the stay is procedural, preserves the status quo, and does not set aside or displace the High Court's findings; the substantive issues will be addressed in the appeal Borneo Post Online,Malay Mail,Malay Mail.
What is the federal government appealing?
According to the Attorney General's Chambers and court reporting, Putrajaya says it is not appealing Sabah's 40% entitlement formula itself, but is challenging parts of the High Court decision, including aspects of interpretation and the implementation timetable Malay Mail,東方網 馬來西亞東方日報,BERNAMA.
The receipts — 29 sources
Other coverage (29)
A news briefing built to show both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.