California woman in landmark lawsuit testifies Instagram and YouTube dominated her childhood and harmed her mental health
The facts
- The plaintiff, known in court as Kaley G.M., is a 20-year-old California woman suing Meta’s Instagram and Google’s YouTube in a civil trial in Los Angeles over alleged social media addiction and resulting mental health harms.
- Kaley G.M. testified that she began using YouTube at about age 6 and Instagram at about age 9, and that as a child she spent all or nearly all of her time on these platforms and struggled to separate herself from them.
- She told the jury that her heavy use of YouTube and Instagram contributed to anxiety, depression, body-image issues or body dysmorphia, and feelings of social isolation.
- Kaley testified that her social media use disrupted her sleep and school performance, reduced her in-person social life, and strained her relationships with her family.
- She said that as her mental health worsened she experienced suicidal thoughts and engaged in self-harm as a coping mechanism during childhood.
- Meta and Google deny that Instagram and YouTube are responsible for Kaley’s mental health problems, with the defense highlighting her difficult or dysfunctional family background and offline troubles as alternative explanations.
- Executives or senior representatives from Meta and YouTube have testified in the trial, with YouTube’s vice president of engineering Cristos Goodrow telling the court that YouTube is not designed to maximize time spent on the platform but to provide value to users.
- This case is one of a small group of bellwether or test trials whose outcomes are expected to influence or set the tone for thousands of similar lawsuits accusing social media companies of harming children’s mental health through allegedly addictive design features.
Context
What exactly is Kaley G.M. alleging Instagram and YouTube did to her?
Kaley G.M. alleges that Instagram and YouTube were designed in ways that hooked her on the platforms from a very young age, leading her to spend nearly all her time on them and making it extremely difficult to cut back Court House News Se…,NDTV,CBS News,Manila times,Times of India,Straits Times. She says this compulsive use contributed to anxiety, depression, body dysmorphia or insecurity about her looks, social isolation, poor sleep, declining school performance, strained family relationships, suicidal thoughts and self-harm behaviors during her childhood and adolescence Court House News Se…,France 24,WSJ,Hindu,Manila times,Times of India,cnbctv18.com,Le Journal de Montr….
How are Meta and Google responding to the allegations in court?
Meta and Google deny that their platforms caused Kaley’s mental health problems and dispute that her use of Instagram and YouTube amounted to addiction or was the companies’ responsibility France 24,BBC,Reuters,Manila times. Their defense has emphasized her difficult or dysfunctional family environment and offline issues as key contributors to her condition, and YouTube executive Cristos Goodrow has testified that YouTube is not designed to maximize time spent but to deliver value to users France 24,Le Monde,BFMTV,Reuters,Le Parisien,La Presse.ca,Le Journal de Montr….
Why is this trial considered a landmark or bellwether case?
The lawsuit is one of a handful of bellwether or test cases selected from among hundreds or thousands of similar suits that accuse major social media platforms of harming young users’ mental health through allegedly addictive design features Daily Mail,Yahoo! Finance,CBS News,Reuters,U.S. News & World R…,Los Angeles Times,NZ Herald,Straits Times. Its outcome is expected to guide settlement talks, legal strategies, and potential liability in many other cases, effectively setting the tone for how courts may handle broader claims against Meta, Google and other social media companies Daily Mail,Yahoo! Finance,CBS News,Reuters,U.S. News & World R…,Los Angeles Times,NZ Herald,Straits Times.
The receipts — 73 sources
Wire services (11)
Other coverage (62)
A news briefing built to show both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.