Federal authorities deport Minnesota man after state pardon of child sex abuse conviction
How left and right are reading this
- Both agree
- A Minnesota pardon did not settle Vang’s fate, leaving the pardon’s immigration effect unresolved while federal authorities still executed a final removal order.
- They split on
- Whether the story is about immigration enforcement overriding a state’s act of clemency, or about federal immigration authority holding even when a state points the other way.
The Facts
- The Department of Homeland Security said Tou Lue Vang was deported from the United States after receiving a pardon from Minnesota officials last month.
- Vang's pardon was granted by Minnesota's Board of Pardons, which includes Gov. Tim Walz, Attorney General Keith Ellison and Chief Justice Natalie Hudson.
- Vang, 42, had been convicted in 2005 or 2006 in connection with sexually abusing a 10-year-old girl, and the conviction was the basis for his immigration consequences.
- Before the pardon, Vang had lost his permanent legal status and was under a final removal order to Laos.
- Vang remained in the United States for years after the removal order because Laos had not been regularly accepting deportees.
- Secretary of State Marco Rubio said he revoked or terminated Vang's legal status before federal agents removed him from the country.
- The case matters beyond one deportation because it raised a conflict between a state pardon that erased a criminal conviction and the federal government's authority over immigration enforcement.
- One unresolved point is the exact legal effect of the Minnesota pardon on Vang's immigration case, since federal authorities proceeded with deportation despite the state clemency action.
Analytical frames for this storyTap to explore
Context
Why was Vang facing deportation in the first place?
According to multiple reports, Vang lost his permanent legal status because of his child sexual abuse conviction and was issued a final removal order to Laos in 2006 NYT,NewsMax,Bring Me The News.
Why did he remain in the United States for so long after that removal order?
Reports say Laos had limited or refused acceptance of deportees for years, which meant Vang stayed in Minnesota despite the removal order Guardian,UPI,Bring Me The News.
What role did the Minnesota pardon play?
The pardon erased Vang's state criminal record, and it came as he was facing deportation, but federal authorities still removed him after Rubio said he terminated Vang's legal status NYT,Fox News,FOX 9 Minneapolis-S….
Facts first. Then every angle.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief — the facts everyone agrees on, then the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.
View all 57 sources
Wire services (1)
Independent coverage (50)
Oil City NewsAllemand's DUI lawyer may face sanctions, indirect contempt ...
Mail OnlinePedophile migrant is seen being marched onto plane by ICE
NewsMaxRubio Revokes Status, DHS Deports Walz-Pardoned Sex Offender
NTDRubio Deports Laos Man Convicted of Sexually Abusing 10-Year...
UPIICE deports pardoned child rapist 20 years after removal ord...
Bradenton HeraldICE deports pardoned child rapist 20 years after removal ord...
The Nerd Stash'Walz Is a Disgrace': Rubio Wins Praise for Deporting Child ...
Twin CitiesMan Minnesota pardoned for child sex abuse deported
INFORUMUS deports man who was pardoned by Walz, Ellison
Bring Me The NewsFeds deport Minnesota man pardoned by Walz over 2005 child s...
AM 1390 KRFOMinnesota Sex Offender Deported After Controversial Pardon
https://www.valleynewslive.comDEPORTED: DHS Removes Convicted Child Rapist Pardoned by Min...
www.independentsentinel.comWalz's Pardoned Child Rapist Was Deported Anyway
BreitbartICE Deports Illegal Alien Child Rapist Pardoned by Gov. Tim ...
mintRubio says convicted child rapist pardoned by Minnesota Gove...
acecomments.mu.nuMarco Rubio Laughs at Tim Walz's Attempt to Shield a Child R...
The GuardianMarco Rubio announces deportation of Minnesota man pardoned ...
The Mighty 790 KFGO | KFGOAfter being pardoned in Minnesota, Laotian national Tou Lue ...
TheBlazeMarco Rubio takes action to END the threat from Tim Walz's i...
DNyuzICE Deports Immigrant Who Was Pardoned for Sex Abuse Convict...
77 WABC RadioMinnesota Man Pardoned for Child Sex Crime Deported After Fe...
The New York TimesICE Deports Immigrant Who Was Pardoned for Sex Abuse Convict...
Mirage NewsTrump Deports Pardoned Child Rapist from Minnesota
World Tribune: Window on the Real WorldDeported: Rubio terminates legal status of child rapist pard...
Power LineDeported
Shore News NetworkConvicted Child Rapist Pardoned by Gov. Tim Walz Deported to...
Star TribuneU.S. deports Hmong man who was pardoned by Minnesota officia...
Washington ExaminerRubio reveals child rapist pardoned by Walz deported from US
Star TribuneVang: Let's look more carefully at Minnesota's pardon of a s...
WND'Heinous crimes': Rubio announces child rapist pardoned by T...
One America News NetworkRubio steps in, deports illegal alien child rapist pardoned ...
Internewscast JournalConvicted Child Rapist Deported Under Trump After Governor's...
Washington TimesTrump admin deports criminal migrant pardoned by Tim Walz
Fox WilmingtonMarco Rubio steps in after Tim Walz pardoned illegal alien c...
American GreatnessMarco Rubio Steps in to Facilitate Removal of Illegal Alien ...
The Daily CallerICE Deports Illegal Alien Child Rapist Previously Pardoned B...
Mirage NewsVisa Revoked for Foreign Child Predator
The Daily WireMarco Rubio Just Dropped The Hammer After Tim Walz's Pardon ...
The Free Press - TampaOverriding Walz's Pardon: Feds Strip Status And Deport Minne...
CBS NewsMinnesota immigrant pardoned for sexually abusing child depo...
American ThinkerTim Walz rushed to shield a convicted child rapist alien fro...
Conservative News TodayRubio deports convicted child rapist despite Tim Walz pardon
Conservative News TodayIllegal arrested for raping 9-year-old special needs child i...
Mail OnlinePedo deported by Trump after woke gov. pardoned him for rape...
Power LineA Happy Ending
Sean HannityMarco Rubio Says Child Rapist Pardoned by Tim Walz Has Been ...
Le·gal In·sur·rec·tionRubio: U.S. Deports Convicted Child Rapist Pardoned by Walz
New York PostICE deports illegal migrant pardoned by Minnesota Gov. Tim W...
ObjectivistMarco Rubio Intervenes After Tim Walz Pardons Illegal Alien ...
RedstateWatch: Rubio Steps in to Save the Day After Walz Pardons Chi...
About these frames
The Guardian: Sanctity, degradation, bodily autonomy, moral boundaries, human dignity, bioethics, environmental purity. Where are the lines that should not be crossed?
The Architect: Stability, law, enforcement, institutional design, separation of powers, regulatory process, rule of law. How are order and governance maintained?
The First Responder: Who gets hurt or helped. Quality of life, vulnerable groups, public health, human cost and benefit.
The Watchdog: Wrongdoing, responsibility, corruption, transparency. Who knew what, when, and what they did about it.
The Bridge Builder: Heritage, community, national identity, social cohesion, cultural preservation, trust, polarization. What does this mean for who people are and how they hold together?
See this differently than someone you know would? Two ways to keep it going.
The dial works on any URL — paste an article you read elsewhere this week.