Iran says U.S. deal requires Israeli withdrawal from Lebanon, while terms remain unclear
The facts
- Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi said the end of the war must include an end to fighting in Lebanon and the withdrawal of Israeli forces from territory they occupied there.
- Araghchi said continued Israeli presence in Lebanese territory, and further Israeli attacks on Lebanon, would be treated by Iran as violations of the U.S.-Iran memorandum of understanding.
- Iranian officials have described the memorandum as requiring a ceasefire or end to hostilities on all fronts, including Lebanon.
- The memorandum between the United States and Iran has not been released publicly in full, leaving its exact terms unclear.
- Iranian officials said a new round of U.S.-Iran negotiations is likely to begin Friday in Switzerland after the memorandum is signed.
- Iranian officials said the follow-on negotiations are expected to last 60 days and address a final agreement covering Iran's nuclear program and sanctions relief.
- The Lebanon issue is a potential point of tension for the broader deal because Israel is not a formal party to the U.S.-Iran agreement, even as Iran says Israel's actions are covered by it.
Context
What did Iran say the agreement requires on Lebanon?
Araghchi said the agreement must end the war on all fronts, including Lebanon, and that Israeli forces must withdraw from Lebanese territory occupied during the war; he also said any further Israeli attack on Lebanon would be considered a violation of the memorandum CBS News,Deutsche Welle,Business Standard.
Why is there uncertainty about this condition?
The memorandum has not been published in full, so outside observers cannot verify its exact terms, and Israel is not a formal party to the U.S.-Iran deal even though Iran says Israel's conduct is part of the arrangement Bluefield Daily Tel…,Deutsche Welle,Globe and Mail.
What happens next in the U.S.-Iran process?
Iranian officials said the memorandum is expected to be signed in Switzerland and that a new round of negotiations on a final agreement would likely begin Friday, with talks expected to run for 60 days and cover nuclear issues and sanctions relief وكاله عمون …,News18,Milliyet.
Common ground, and where they split
- Common ground
- An unpublished U.S.-Iran memorandum is already being asked to govern fighting in Lebanon even though Israel is not a formal party, making the deal’s scope and enforceability a live issue before broader nuclear and sanctions talks begin.
- Where Left and Right split
- Lebanon being inseparable from any real end to hostilities, or Iran using an unclear memorandum to claim authority over a nonparty’s actions and complicate the broader deal from the start.
How left and right read it
The key issue here is that Iran is treating Lebanon as part of any real end to hostilities, saying Israeli forces must withdraw and further attacks would violate the memorandum. Because the agreement has not been released publicly and Israel is not a formal party even as its actions are being treated as covered, a major regional security question is being carried into follow-on talks on the nuclear program and sanctions relief.
The key fact here is that Iran is asserting the power to define violations of a U.S.-Iran memorandum whose full terms have not been released publicly. That matters even more because Iran says Israel’s actions in Lebanon are covered by the deal despite Israel not being a formal party, which makes the coming negotiations over a final agreement look vulnerable to ambiguity from the start.
The receipts — 100 sources
Wire services (13)
Other coverage (87)
A news briefing built to show both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.