Judge allows parts of Trump’s $15 billion defamation lawsuit against The New York Times to proceed
|
The facts
- Judge Steven D. Merryday allowed parts of Trump’s defamation lawsuit against The New York Times and Penguin Random House to proceed.
- Trump seeks $15 billion in the lawsuit.
- Merryday dismissed two claims in Trump’s lawsuit.
- The ruling allowed claims involving seven allegedly defamatory statements to continue.
- Surviving claims concern allegations that Trump committed tax-related or other financial crimes.
- The case concerns the book “Lucky Loser,” written by New York Times reporters, and Times reporting about Trump.
- The New York Times and Penguin Random House have said the lawsuit lacks legal merit.
- The ruling keeps the case alive but does not determine whether the defendants defamed Trump.
Context
Which claims can Trump still pursue?
The surviving claims involve seven statements, including statements in “Lucky Loser” and a Times article, that concerned alleged tax fraud, tax evasion, money laundering or related conduct. Fox News Hindustan Times Hollywood Reporter
What did the judge decide about the evidence behind the allegations?
Merryday found Trump plausibly alleged that some assertions of complex tax crimes lacked adequate expert support, allowing those claims to proceed at this stage. POLITICO infobae Variety
Does the ruling mean Trump has won the case?
No. The decision denied a full dismissal and allows portions of the case to continue, but it does not establish that defamation occurred. NYT Straits Times
Common ground, and where they split
- Common ground
- Merryday's ruling is partial and inconclusive: two claims were dismissed while seven defamatory-statement claims survive, with no finding yet on whether anything was actually false.
- Where Left and Right split
- The left and the right split on whether this $15 billion suit chills a newspaper or forces a serious charge to be proven.
- Why they differ
- The two sides split on trust in institutions: one reads surviving procedural steps as courts checking press power, the other as courts validating press accountability, so the same ruling confirms opposite priors.
How left and right read it
A $15 billion demand against a newspaper and a publisher is a cost in itself, because the price of defending reporting is paid long before any court decides whether a word of it was false. The Times and Penguin Random House call the suit legally meritless. So the question is who can still afford to publish while a president keeps racking up procedural wins.
“It is another win for Trump in his long-running legal campaign against media companies that he accuses of treating him unfairly.” — The Independent
Accusing a man of tax and financial crimes is a serious charge, and anyone who publishes it should have to stand behind it in court like everyone else. Merryday did not wave the case through; he dismissed two claims yet let seven statements proceed. The Times and Penguin Random House call the suit meritless. That is now a question for proof, not for assertion.
Seven claims survive, which means proof and the price of defending against proof now run on the same clock.
The receipts — 67 sources
Wire services (6)
Other coverage (61)
A news briefing built to show both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.