Federal Judge Permanently Bars Release of Jack Smith’s Trump Classified Documents Report
The facts
- On Monday, U.S. District Judge Aileen Cannon permanently barred the Justice Department from releasing the second volume of former special counsel Jack Smith’s report on President Donald Trump’s handling of classified documents after his first term in office.
- Cannon’s order grants requests from Trump and two former co-defendants, Walt Nauta and Carlos de Oliveira, to keep Volume II of the report under seal and prohibits the attorney general and the Justice Department from releasing or sharing its information or conclusions outside the department.
- Judge Cannon found that releasing the report would be a “manifest injustice” to Trump and his co-defendants because it would publicly detail substantial allegations of criminal wrongdoing in a case that was dismissed before reaching a jury or trial.
- Cannon had previously dismissed the classified documents case in 2024 after ruling that Jack Smith was unlawfully or unconstitutionally appointed as special counsel, and the Justice Department dropped its appeal after Trump won the 2024 presidential election.
- The underlying criminal case had accused Trump of unlawfully retaining classified or national defense documents at his Mar-a-Lago residence after leaving office and obstructing government efforts to retrieve them, resulting in an indictment in 2023.
- Cannon’s ruling means that substantial information about one of the four criminal cases Trump faced after leaving office will not be disclosed to the public, ending efforts by advocates and groups that had sought the report’s release.
- In her order, Cannon criticized Smith for continuing to compile a final report for the attorney general after she had dismissed the case, describing this as a “brazen stratagem” to defy her dismissal ruling.
- Smith’s investigation into Trump produced a two-volume report, with the first volume addressing Trump’s alleged efforts to overturn the 2020 election and the second focusing on the classified documents case; the first volume was released publicly in early 2025, while the second will now remain sealed.
Context
What exactly does Judge Cannon’s order prevent the Justice Department from doing with Jack Smith’s report?
Judge Cannon’s order permanently bars the Justice Department and the attorney general from releasing, distributing, conveying, or sharing any information or conclusions contained in Volume II of Jack Smith’s final report, or drafts of it, with anyone outside the department, effectively keeping the report from the public and Congress Fox News,NY Post,CBS News,CBS News,mint,Reuters.
Why did Judge Cannon say releasing the report would be unfair to Trump and his co-defendants?
Cannon wrote that releasing the report would be a “manifest injustice” because it would publicly air detailed allegations of criminal wrongdoing in a case that was dismissed on the ground that the special counsel was unlawfully appointed and that never went to trial, thereby undermining the presumption of innocence for Trump and his co-defendants Walt Nauta and Carlos de Oliveira 7 News Miami,USA Today,Newsweek,WSJ,CBS News,Reuters.
How does this ruling fit into the broader history of the Trump classified documents case?
Smith secured a 2023 indictment accusing Trump of unlawfully retaining classified or national defense documents at Mar-a-Lago and obstructing efforts to retrieve them, but Cannon dismissed the case in 2024 after finding Smith’s appointment unlawful, and the Justice Department dropped its appeal following Trump’s 2024 election victory; her new order now also blocks public release of Smith’s final report on that investigation 7 News Miami,Axios,NDTV,CNBC,Independent,mint,Reuters,Bloomberg Business.
The receipts — 100 sources
Wire services (10)
Other coverage (90)
A news briefing built to show both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.