Federal Judge Rules Trump Administration’s Third-Country Deportation Policy Unlawful and Pauses Ruling for 15 Days
The facts
- U.S. District Judge Brian E. Murphy in Massachusetts ruled that the Trump administration’s policy of deporting migrants to “third countries” that are not their own is unlawful and must be set aside.
- Murphy’s ruling concerns a Department of Homeland Security policy that allowed immigration authorities to deport migrants to countries other than their country of origin, often with little or no advance notice and without first giving them an opportunity to object.
- The judge found that migrants subject to third-country deportations must receive “meaningful notice” and a chance to challenge their removal, including the opportunity to raise fears of persecution or torture in the destination country.
- Murphy paused or suspended the effect of his ruling for 15 days to give the Trump administration time to file an appeal.
- The case arises from a class-action lawsuit filed by noncitizens against the Department of Homeland Security challenging its third-country removal policy.
- Murphy’s decision declares a DHS policy directive, adopted as part of the Trump administration’s broader immigration crackdown, invalid on due process grounds.
- The U.S. Supreme Court has previously intervened in this litigation, including by issuing emergency stays that allowed at least one flight carrying migrants to war-torn South Sudan, where they had no ties, to proceed.
- The Trump administration is expected to appeal Murphy’s ruling, and both the judge and the parties anticipate that the legality of the third-country deportation policy may ultimately be decided by the U.S. Supreme Court.
Context
What is the Trump administration’s third-country deportation policy?
The third-country deportation policy is a Department of Homeland Security directive that allowed immigration authorities to remove migrants from the United States to countries that are not their own and where they may have no ties, rather than first attempting removal to their home country or to countries previously designated in their removal orders NYT,Fox News,Yahoo News,CBS News,CBS News,CBS News,mint,Reuters,HuffPost. Under this policy, officers could carry out such deportations with little advance notice and without giving migrants a prior opportunity to contest being sent to these alternate destinations Fox News,Yahoo News,CBS News,CBS News,CBS News,Al Jazeera Online,Reuters.
Why did Judge Murphy rule the third-country deportation policy unlawful?
Judge Murphy concluded that the policy violated due process because it allowed the government to deport people to third countries without providing “meaningful notice” or a real opportunity to raise fears of persecution or torture or otherwise challenge their removal NYT,Daily Mail,Hindustan Times,USA Today,NBC News,mint,Al Jazeera Online,Reuters. He wrote that sending migrants to unfamiliar and potentially dangerous countries without such protections is “not fine, nor is it legal,” and that the policy effectively extinguished valid legal challenges by carrying out removals before they could be heard Daily Mail,Hindustan Times,USA Today,mint,Al Jazeera Online,Reuters.
What happens next after this ruling?
Because Murphy stayed his decision for 15 days, the third-country deportation policy is not immediately halted, giving the Trump administration time to file an appeal Owensboro Messenger…,Owensboro Messenger…,Guardian,Daily Mail,CBS News,CBS News,Hindu,Chosun.com,Reuters. The Department of Homeland Security has indicated it will seek further review, and both the judge and multiple reports note that the case is likely to return to the U.S. Supreme Court, which has already issued emergency stays in earlier stages of this litigation Guardian,India Today,CBS News,CBS News,CBS News,Chosun.com,Al Jazeera Online,Reuters.
The receipts — 97 sources
Wire services (6)
Other coverage (91)
A news briefing built to show both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.