US Judge Dismisses Criminal Fraud and Bribery Charges Against Gautam Adani While Criticizing Justice Department's Handling
The facts
- U.S. District Judge Nicholas Garaufis of the Eastern District of New York on Monday granted the Justice Department's Rule 48(a) motion to dismiss the indictment against Gautam Adani, Sagar Adani and former Adani Green Energy CEO Vneet Jaain.
- The dismissal is with prejudice, meaning the charges cannot be refiled; sources note it does not amount to a ruling on the merits of the underlying allegations.
- The 2024 indictment alleged that Adani and co-defendants agreed to pay bribes to Indian government officials to secure solar energy supply contracts and then misled U.S. investors and lenders; prosecutors cited figures of more than $250 million in alleged bribes.
- In a 47-page ruling, Garaufis criticized the Justice Department's process, writing that irregularities in the decision to dismiss were "concerning" and that Principal Associate Deputy Attorney General Trent McCotter reached the decision largely in collaboration with defense counsel and seemingly without input from FBI and SEC investigators or the prosecutors who brought the case, which he called "highly unusual."
- Before granting the motion, the judge questioned prosecutors about their reasoning and asked Adani directly whether anything had been promised in exchange for dropping the case; Adani had pledged in November 2024, before the indictment was unsealed, to invest $10 billion in the United States.
- Garaufis concluded that the $10 billion investment pledge did not factor into the Justice Department's decision to seek dismissal.
- The Justice Department moved in May to drop the case, arguing that continuing the prosecution was not in the U.S. public interest and citing the largely foreign nature of the alleged conduct, difficulties obtaining evidence and jurisdictional issues.
- Adani and the Adani Group have consistently denied wrongdoing; after the ruling Adani wrote on X that he welcomed the decision "with humility and deep respect for the judicial process."
- Shares of Adani Group companies, including Adani Green Energy, Adani Enterprises and Adani Ports, traded higher in India following the ruling.
Context
Did the judge dismiss every count against every defendant?
No. CBS News reported that while Garaufis dismissed the charges against Adani and several co-defendants, he refused to dismiss two counts against five other co-defendants, saying the Justice Department had not given him a sufficient reason to do so Aol,CBS News. Adani had been indicted in November 2024 along with seven others CNBC.
What happened to the related civil case?
Hindustan Times reported that the district court also finalized a settlement between the Adanis and the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission under which they will pay $18 million without admitting guilt, resolving the civil securities fraud claims Hindustan Times. NDTV likewise noted a civil penalty component to the SEC case NDTV.
How does this fit into the Justice Department's broader record under the current administration?
Reuters reported that the dismissal marked the latest instance in which federal prosecutors sought to abandon a high-profile white-collar criminal prosecution during President Donald Trump's second term Aol,Indian Express. The New York Times characterized the dismissal request as contentious and noted it came after Adani offered billions of dollars in U.S. investment NYT.
Common ground, and where they split
- Common ground
- Charges alleging more than $250 million in bribes are gone for good with nothing resolved on the merits, and the dismissal process warranted the judge's scrutiny.
- Where Left and Right split
- A political appointee settling a billionaire's case with defense counsel over the investigators' heads, or how far American criminal law should reach into foreign conduct.
How left and right read it
Whether a billionaire faces a bribery indictment should be decided by the investigators who built the case, not worked out between a political appointee and defense counsel. Garaufis said as much: irregularities he called concerning, a decision reached largely with the defense and seemingly without input from FBI and SEC investigators or the prosecutors themselves. Charges alleging more than $250 million in bribes are now gone for good, with nothing resolved on the merits. Accountability that dissolves at the top is not accountability.
“A federal judge on Monday dismissed the criminal fraud charges against Indian billionaire Gautam Adani and several of his co-defendants, after politically appointed leaders in the Justice Department decided to kill the case in May.” — CBS News
Reaching American criminal law into bribes allegedly paid to Indian officials for Indian solar contracts was always a stretch — the Department itself cited largely foreign conduct, evidence it could not obtain, and jurisdictional problems. The judge still made them answer, asking Adani directly whether anything had been promised and finding the $10 billion pledge played no part. Nothing about the allegations was resolved. Where should a U.S. indictment's reach end?
“A dismissal with prejudice permanently closes the criminal proceedings and bars the charges from being refiled. It does not, however, amount to a judicial finding on the underlying allegations.” — The Telegraph
The receipts — 100 sources
Wire services (4)
Other coverage (96)
A news briefing built to show both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.