Federal judge orders New York City to comply with ICE subpoena for Bronx shelter records
|
The facts
- U.S. District Judge Lewis A. Kaplan ordered New York City to comply with an ICE subpoena.
- The subpoena seeks names and birth dates of residents at a Bronx homeless shelter.
- ICE says the records are needed to investigate whether shelter residents are subject to deportation.
- The federal government narrowed the request to residents with certain serious criminal histories.
- A special master will oversee collection and disclosure of the requested names.
- City officials had challenged the subpoena and sought to block disclosure.
- Kaplan ruled that the city had not shown producing the list would be unduly burdensome.
Context
What information must the city provide?
The subpoena seeks the names and birth dates of certain residents of a Bronx homeless shelter, with the request narrowed to people with specified serious criminal histories. POLITICO Daily News
Why does ICE want the records?
ICE says it is investigating whether people at the shelter are in the country illegally and are subject to deportation. POLITICO Washington Examiner Gothamist
How will the disclosure be handled?
The federal government agreed to use a special master to collect and provide the names covered by the narrowed request. Washington Examiner Daily News PJ Media
Common ground, and where they split
- Common ground
- Both frame the ruling as turning narrowly on whether the city proved the narrowed, special-master-supervised request was unduly burdensome, not on ICE's underlying authority to seek the records.
- Where Left and Right split
- The left and the right split on whether the city was shielding residents or dodging a reasonable subpoena.
- Why they differ
- The divide is over values: whether the measure of harm should be the city's administrative burden, as the ruling asked, or the exposure risk borne by the residents whose names get collected.
How left and right read it
A shelter has to be somewhere people can enter without becoming a target, yet the order turned on whether producing names and birth dates was unduly burdensome for the city. That is the wrong measure. The cost lands on the residents whose names a special master will collect, not on the city's paperwork, so the challenge was right and the city should keep shielding the people in its care.
The request was narrowed to residents with certain serious criminal histories and a special master will oversee the disclosure, so the only thing City Hall actually had to prove was undue burden — and Judge Kaplan found it had not. Comply. If names and birth dates are too much to ask about people with serious criminal records, what exactly would the city consider a reasonable request?
“ICE wants the names and birth dates of homeless men staying at a Bronx shelter to determine whether they are illegal immigrants subject to deportation.” — Washington Examiner
The legal question was narrow — undue burden — but the list it produces could follow residents straight into deportation proceedings.
The receipts — 7 sources
Other coverage (7)
A news briefing built to show both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.