Justice Department investigates TV networks over White House pool coverage suspension
Rights & JusticeWell-covered
|
The Facts
- The Justice Department is investigating ABC, CBS, CNN, NBC and Fox News over possible antitrust violations.
- The investigation concerns the networks’ temporary suspension of White House television pool coverage.
- Justice Department officials sought network communications and materials related to the White House television pool.
- The networks suspended the pool system for several days last month.
- The suspension followed the White House’s decision to bar CNN, MS NOW and Politico from its grounds.
- The White House television pool rotates coverage duties and distributes footage to other news outlets.
- The Justice Department said group boycotts among commercial competitors can violate the Sherman Act.
Context
What is the White House television pool?
It is a rotating arrangement in which participating television networks cover the president and share footage or reporting with other news organizations. NYT BBC
What prompted the networks to pause pool coverage?
The networks paused the arrangement after the White House barred CNN, MS NOW and Politico from its grounds. BBC Washington Post Yahoo!
Where Left and Right agree, and where they split
- Where Left and Right agree
- Five rival networks jointly suspended the shared pool system for several days after the White House barred CNN, MS NOW and Politico, and both sides agree this joint suspension is what triggered DOJ scrutiny under the Sherman Act.
- Where Left and Right split
- The left and the right split on whether the DOJ probe punishes press solidarity or enforces antitrust law evenly.
- Why they won’t converge
- The divide is one of values: whether journalists coordinating in solidarity count as protected newsgathering conduct or as commercial collusion subject to antitrust scrutiny like any other industry.
How left and right read it
Left says
Antitrust law exists to protect the public from concentrated economic power, not to punish reporters for standing together. Yet the Sherman Act is being invoked because five networks briefly paused a pool that only rotates coverage duties and shares footage, after the White House barred CNN, MS NOW and Politico from its grounds. Demanding their internal communications turns a competition statute into a weapon against the press.
“The Justice Department's investigation marks a sharp escalation in the administration's use of its powers against perceived enemies in the press.” — Washington Post
Right says
Antitrust law binds every commercial competitor, and broadcasters are not carved out of it. Five rival networks jointly halted the pool for several days after the White House barred CNN, MS NOW and Politico, so concerted action among competitors is a fair question under the Sherman Act, which is exactly why officials sought their communications. Equal application of the law is the point.
“ABC, CBS, CNN, NBC, and Fox News were told on Friday to provide "communications and materials" related to the White House TV press pool, according to the New York Times, in an escalation against legacy media companies with which Trump has long feuded.” — Washington Examiner
A rotation of camera duty is now cast as a boycott. The fight is whether coordinated journalism counts as commerce.
The receipts — 100 sources
Wire services (3)
Independent coverage (97)
Deutsche WelleEEUU investiga a cadenas de TV por detener cobertura a Trump
Vorarlberg OnlineTrump: US-Justiz ermittelt gegen CNN, Fox News und drei weit...
Vorarlberg OnlineTrump-Sende-Stopp: Untersuchung gegen US-Medien
La Libre.beÉtats-Unis : cinq grandes chaînes de télévision visées par u...
N-tvNach Trump-Boykott: US-Justizministerium prüft Klage gegen F...
SudOuest.frÉtats-Unis : le ministère de la Justice enquête sur cinq cha...
Le SoirLe ministère américain de la Justice enquête sur cinq chaîne...
NEWS.amМинюст США начал расследование против пяти телеканалов из-за...
Der TagesspiegelNach Boykott von CNN & Co.: Trump lässt Verstöße von US-Send...
www.Bluewin.chU.S. Government Investigates Antitrust Violations by Broadca...
The News InternationalDOJ probes major TV networks over coordinated Trump press po...
Sudinfo.beBras de fer entre Donald Trump et les médias : cinq grandes ...
GMX NewsKartellklage-Drohung: Trump-Regierung macht Druck auf unlieb...
Yahoo!Departamento de Justicia de EEUU investiga a cadenas de TV p...
Rai newsDipartimento Giustizia Usa indaga sui network tv che hanno i...
Free Malaysia TodayUS justice dept probes TV networks over pool coverage
elEconomista.esJusticia de EEUU investiga si el boicot de las cadenas de te...
Hindustan TimesJustice department probes TV networks over suspension of Tru...
Nezavisne novinePokrenuta istraga protiv CNN-a, Foxa, NBC-a, CBS-a i ABC-a
TheJournal.ieTrump's justice department investigates five US broadcasters...
BildDonald Trump gegen die TV-Giganten! Justizministerium ermitt...
The Jerusalem PostUS DOJ launches investigation into news networks for possibl...
Oxu.AzМинюст США начал расследование против крупнейших телеканалов
Berliner ZeitungNach Protest gegen Trumps Pressebann: US-Justiz ermittelt ge...
RNZTrump's Justice Department investigates TV networks over res...
MoneyControlTrump administration launches antitrust investigation into m...
DAGOSPIAle roncolate di trump ai media - il dipartimento di giustizi...
Telegram.hrNastavlja se rat Trumpa i medija: Ministarstvo pravosuđa SAD...
Novi listZašto ne dolaze u Bijelu kuću? Trump naredio istragu TV mrež...
vijesti.baTrumpova administracija pokrenula istragu protiv pet najveći...
tportal.hrTrump zbog bojkota krenuo na televizije: Pod istragom čak i ...
KurierTrump gegen die Medien: Jetzt wird gegen CNN und Fox ermitte...
IndexHRTrumpova administracija pokrenula istragu protiv CNN-a, Foxa...
Net.hrTrumpovo ministarstvo ne staje! Pazite što sad istražuju
watson.ch/US-Regierung prüft Kartellrechts-Verstoss bei Sendern
Economic TimesDOJ says it's investigating whether White House TV pool's co...
Anchorage Daily NewsDOJ investigating five TV networks over White House pool cov...
Washington ExaminerJustice Department investigating TV networks that briefly su...
NewsBytesTrump probes TV networks over White House coverage boycott
Al Jazeera OnlineUS opens antitrust probe into TV networks halting Trump cove...
Jutarnji listMinistarstvo pravosuđa SAD-a istražuje televizijske kuće zbo...
Anadolu AjansıUS Justice Department probes major TV networks for suspensio...
vesti.ruМинюст США ведет расследование в отношении крупных американс...
Deutsche WelleUS: Justice Department probes Trump's press pool boycott
РИА НовостиСМИ: в США расследуют приостановку пулового освещения Трампа...
europa pressJusticia de EEUU investiga si el boicot de las cadenas de te...
Zeitungsverlag WaiblingenUS-Regierung prüft Kartellrechts-Verstoß bei Sendern
WEB.DEKartellklage-Drohung: Trump-Regierung macht Druck auf unlieb...
Nordkurier OnlineUS-Regierung prüft Kartellrechts-Verstoß bei Sendern
Volksstimme.deUS-Regierung prüft Kartellrechts-Verstoß bei Sendern
Trierischer Volksfreund. Die Zeitung für die Region Trier/MoselKartellrecht: US-Regierung prüft Kartellrechts-Verstoß bei S...
Radio BielefeldWashington | US-Regierung prüft Kartellrechts-Verstoß bei Se...
NZ HeraldUS Justice Department probes five TV networks over antitrust...
Business StandardDOJ probes whether White House TV pool coverage halt violate...
The GuardianUS justice department investigating TV networks over Trump p...
eldiario.esLa Administración Trump lanza una investigación contra las p...
Аргументы и фактыNYT сообщила о начале расследования против телеканалов из пу...
L’actualitéWashington veut enquêter sur le boycott médiatique de la cou...
BBCМинюст США расследует бойкот телеканалами из президентского ...
AolJustice Department investigating major TV networks over susp...
AolDOJ investigating TV networks over suspension of press pool ...
CBS NewsJustice Department investigating TV networks over suspension...
The TelegraphJustice Department investigates major US news networks over ...
CNN EspañolEl Departamento de Justicia investiga a principales cadenas ...
USA TodayDOJ launches antitrust probe of TV networks over Trump pool ...
MoneyControlTrump administration probes CNN, Fox News, other TV networks...
NewsweekWhat is the Sherman Act? Why DOJ investigating networks over...
CNN InternationalTrump's DOJ probes major TV networks over response to White ...
matzav.comDOJ TARGETS FIVE TV GIANTS: Justice Department Launches Anti...
TelemundoEl Departamento de Justicia de Trump lanza investigación con...
The Times of IndiaBreaking News Live Updates: Republican lawmakers to move Bil...
Taegan Goddard's Political WireJustice Department Is Investigating TV Networks
Spiegel OnlineDonald Trump: Justizministerium geht gegen TV-Sender wegen K...
mintDOJ Probes TV Networks Over White House Coverage Decisions |...
The Hollywood ReporterJustice Department Investigating TV Networks Over Decision t...
The Wall Street JournalJustice Department Probes TV Networks Over Suspension of Tru...
Washington PostDOJ investigating five TV networks over White House pool cov...
BBCJustice Department investigating television networks over Tr...
EL PAÍSEl Departamento de Justicia de EE UU investiga la cobertura ...
La Silla RotaTrump va contra medios que protestaron por su veto a CNN, MS...
Raw StoryTrump admin demands documents in 'profound escalation' of fe...
Bloomberg BusinessDOJ Probes TV Networks Over White House Coverage Decisions
India TodayTrump coverage boycott puts US TV networks under probe
Hindustan TimesWhy is the Justice Department investigating ABC, CBS, CNN, N...
MediaiteTrump's DOJ Is Investigating Whether TV Networks Broke The L...
Московский КомсомолецВ США начали расследование против крупнейших телеканалов
Vorarlberg OnlineErmittlungen gegen US-TV-Sender wegen Trump-Boykotts
ТАССNYT сообщила о начале расследования против телеканалов из пу...
The Straits TimesUS Justice Department probes Trump pool coverage
TimesNowTrump's Press War Escalates as DOJ Investigates 5 Major TV N...
newsORF.atUS-Justizministerium ermittelt gegen TV-Sender
The Times of IsraelUS Justice Department probing TV networks over decision to b...
ANSA.it'Il Dipartimento di Giustizia Usa indaga sui network tv per ...
Giornale di brescia'Il Dipartimento di Giustizia Usa indaga sui network tv per ...
The New York TimesJustice Dept. Is Investigating TV Networks Over Trump Pool C...
RTE.ieUS department probes TV networks over Trump pool boycott
The Spokesman ReviewJustice Department probes TV networks over Trump pool covera...
Facts first. Then every angle.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief — the facts everyone agrees on, then the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.