Jean-Luc Mélenchon faces renewed antisemitism accusations over comments on Jeffrey Epstein name pronunciation at Lyon rally
The facts
- On Thursday, February 26, 2026, Jean‑Luc Mélenchon, leader of La France insoumise, made remarks about the pronunciation of Jeffrey Epstein’s name during a political meeting in Lyon in support of an LFI municipal candidate.
- During the Lyon meeting, Mélenchon said words to the effect of "Je voulais dire Epstine pardon, ça fait plus russe Epstine" and told the audience that they would now say "Epstine" instead of "Epstein" and "Frankenstine" instead of "Frankenstein," prompting laughter in the room.
- These comments sparked a wave of criticism and renewed accusations of antisemitism against Mélenchon from political figures and organizations across the French political spectrum.
- Yonathan Arfi, president of the Representative Council of French Jewish Institutions (CRIF), publicly criticized Mélenchon’s remarks on X, calling the idea that pronouncing "Epstein" in an English way is a manipulation a "conspiracy delirium with real antisemitic overtones" and noting that even a middle‑school student knows the English pronunciation.
- French Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez condemned Mélenchon’s comments as "abject" and said he was playing on an ambiguity that resembled the practices of Dieudonné and sometimes Alain Soral, while also stating that conditions for dissolving La France insoumise were not met.
- Other political leaders, including figures from the left, publicly denounced Mélenchon’s remarks, with some describing them as using the "codes of antisemitism" or comparing him to far‑right polemicist Alain Soral.
- Mélenchon has rejected the accusations of antisemitism, arguing in subsequent statements and posts on X that he was ironizing about a supposed attempt to "Russify" the Epstein affair and denouncing what he calls a manipulative and disproportionate reaction aimed at fueling violence against La France insoumise.
- The controversy comes as La France insoumise is already under pressure in the run‑up to municipal elections, including over the fallout from the death of Quentin Deranque in Lyon and broader debates about the party’s stance on antisemitism since the Hamas attack in Israel in 2023.
Context
What exactly did Mélenchon say about Jeffrey Epstein’s name, and in what context did he make these remarks?
At a February 26 meeting in Lyon supporting LFI municipal candidate Anaïs Belouassa‑Cherifi, Jean‑Luc Mélenchon criticized media coverage of judicial affairs and then turned to the Epstein case, saying, "Je voulais dire Epstine pardon, ça fait plus russe Epstine" and instructing the audience that they would now say "Epstine" instead of "Epstein" and "Frankenstine" instead of "Frankenstein," which drew laughter from the crowd lindependant.fr,Ouest France,Ouest France,BFMTV,20minutes,20minutes.
Why have these comments been labeled antisemitic or conspiratorial by critics?
Critics, including CRIF president Yonathan Arfi, argue that suggesting the English‑style pronunciation of "Epstein" is a deliberate manipulation amounts to a "conspiracy delirium with real antisemitic overtones," invoking classic tropes about hidden plots linked to Jews LaProvence.com,Ouest France,BFMTV. Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez and other politicians say Mélenchon is using the "codes of antisemitism" and playing on an ambiguity reminiscent of figures like Dieudonné and Alain Soral, which they view as normalizing antisemitic insinuations in political discourse TF1 INFO,Le Figaro.fr,Le Figaro.fr,BFMTV.
How has Mélenchon responded to the backlash and accusations of antisemitism?
Mélenchon has firmly denied any antisemitic intent, writing on X that he was mocking a supposed desire to make "Epstine" a more Russian‑sounding name and calling it a "consternante réaction" that some see antisemitism in this joke BFMTV,BFMTV. He argues that the controversy is a "manipulation" and claims that those who constantly bring discussions back to antisemitism are the ones fostering hostility, saying the uproar is being used to fuel violence against La France insoumise lindependant.fr,Le Figaro.fr,Ouest France,Le Monde,Le Monde,BFMTV,BFMTV.
The receipts — 98 sources
Wire services (5)
Other coverage (93)
A news briefing built to show both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.