Kenmore Air seaplane made emergency landing near Sucia Island and caught fire; all 11 aboard were rescued
The Facts
- A Kenmore Air seaplane made an emergency landing near Sucia Island in Washington state and then caught fire.
- The aircraft was a de Havilland DHC-3 Otter carrying 11 people: 10 passengers and one pilot.
- All 11 people on board were accounted for after the incident and were rescued from the water.
- Several people were injured, and some passengers were transported to hospitals for medical evaluation and treatment.
- The plane had departed from Lake Union in Seattle before the accident near Shallow Bay by Sucia Island.
- U.S. Coast Guard, Canadian, and local responders took part in the rescue operation.
- The crash occurred in the San Juan Islands area near the Canadian border, which brought in responders from both sides of the border.
- The cause of the emergency landing was not established in the cited reports at the time of publication.
Context
Where did the crash happen?
The seaplane went down near Shallow Bay by Sucia Island in Washington state's San Juan Islands, north of Seattle and near the Canadian border Investing.com,USA Today,CBC News.
What is known about the people on board?
There were 11 people aboard: 10 passengers and one pilot. All were accounted for after the rescue, and several injured people were taken to hospitals for treatment or evaluation Hindustan Times,CBS News,CNN International.
What remains unclear?
The cited reports say the plane made an emergency landing before catching fire, but they do not establish what caused the emergency or the crash CNN International,Economic Times.
Where Left and Right agree, and where they split
- Where Left and Right agree
- All 11 people were rescued after the seaplane’s emergency landing and fire, and several injuries made the quality of the response the story’s clearest fact.
- Where Left and Right split
- Preserving cross-border public rescue capacity, or disciplined responders and reporters sticking to confirmed facts before assigning cause.
How left and right read it
Left says
A Kenmore Air seaplane carrying 11 people made an emergency landing near Sucia Island and then caught fire; all 11 were rescued from the water, but several were injured and some were taken to hospitals. This is what public safety looks like under pressure: when disaster hits at the border, people depend on coordinated rescue capacity across jurisdictions. Protect that capacity, and treat it as essential.
“A seaplane carrying 11 people crashed and erupted into a fiery blaze off the coast of Washington state, leaving one victim fighting life.” — The Independent
Is this how the left would actually put it?
Right says
Eleven people were on that de Havilland DHC-3 Otter when it made an emergency landing near Sucia Island and caught fire, and every one of them was accounted for after being rescued from the water. Several were injured and some went to hospitals, but the central fact is disciplined competence under extreme conditions, without pretending to know a cause that was not yet established. Accountability to facts matters most.
“Miraculously, all 10 passengers and the pilot were accounted for following the fiery wreck, officials said.” — New York Post
Is this how the right would actually put it?
The receipts — 100 sources
Wire services (10)
APInternational Business Times, Singapore EditionKenmore Air Plane Crash: What We Know After Seaplane Carryin...
Reuters104.1 WIKY | Adult Contemporary RadioSeaplane crashes in Washington state, all 11 people on board...
Independent coverage (90)
YahooKenmore Air: Pilot adjusted flight path due to weather
Yahoo8 released from hospitals after San Juan Islands floatplane ...
97 RockSeaplane Crashed in the San Juan Islands Thursday, All 11 We...
YahooTHE LATEST: All but 3 passengers released from hospital afte...
YahooKenmore Air floatplane debris removed from water after crash...
My Bellingham Now -More details emerge following Sucia Island plane crash
The OlympianCrashed seaplane to be recovered Friday as investigation int...
Eagle-TribuneHow 11 Kenmore Air crash survivors were rescued off Washingt...
TV360 Nigeria11 Rescued As Seaplane Crashes, Catches Fire In Washington
Washington TimesSeaplane crashes in Washington state, all 10 passengers and ...
Arab NewsA seaplane crashes into a remote island north of Seattle but...
NTDSeaplane Carrying 11 Crashes, Catches Fire Near Washington I...
CastanetA seaplane carrying 11 crashes near Saturna Island on the Ca...
Yahoo! FinanceA seaplane carrying 11 crashes near Saturna Island on the Ca...
Barchart.comA seaplane carrying 11 crashes near Saturna Island on the Ca...
Times ColonistSeaplane carrying 11 crashes into San Juan Islands
CBC NewsSeaplane emergency landing near B.C.-Wash. border leaves sev...
MediaiteWATCH: Terrifying Video Shows Seaplane Crash And Burst Into ...
Bothell-Kenmore ReporterKenmore Air seaplane crashes in San Juan Islands - Bothell
Bellevue ReporterKenmore Air seaplane crashes in San Juan Islands - Bellevue ...
The Seattle TimesKenmore Air cancels all Friday flights following crash
KSBYSeaplane carrying 11 crashes into an island near Seattle, al...
KUOW-FM (94.9, Seattle)NTSB investigating Kenmore Air seaplane crash in San Juan Is...
My NorthwestVIDEO: Kenmore Air seaplane crash near Sucia Island; all 11 ...
Extra.ie11 people narrowly escape death after seaplane crashes into ...
YahooKenmore Air cancels all Friday flights after floatplane cras...
Total Pro SportsShocking Footage Shows Seaplane Wobbling Over Water Before C...
The News InternationalKenmore Air seaplane crashes and catches fire near San Juan ...
CHEKKenmore Air seaplane crashes half way between Vancouver Isla...
Economic TimesSeaplane carrying 11 crashes into island north of Seattle, a...
The Seattle TimesWhat we know about the Kenmore Air seaplane crash in San Jua...
East Idaho News11 people rescued after seaplane crashes off Washington coas...
TMZSeaplane Crashes Off Washington Coast, Fiery Wreck On Video
Chemainus Valley Courier11 accounted for after fiery seaplane crash between Vancouve...
The Daily BeastGrammy Winner Pleads Guilty to 'Vicious' Nightclub Bottle At...
The Daily BeastPlane Carrying 11 Bursts Into Flames in Terrifying Crash
CBS NewsSeaplane crashes, catches fire in Puget Sound area north of ...
TribLIVEA seaplane carrying 11 crashes into an island north of Seatt...
Legit.ng - Nigeria news.Kenmore air seaplane crashes and catches fire near Seattle, ...
The IndependentSeaplane with 11 people onboard crashes in fiery blaze off i...
Newser11 Rescued After Seaplane Crash Off Washington Coast
People.comSeaplane Carrying 11 Crashes Before Bursting into Flames off...
YahooSeaplane Carrying 11 Crashes Before Bursting into Flames off...
Pulse24.com Serious injuries after plane crashes off Washington's San Ju...
WMTWVIDEO: Seaplane crashes off Washington coast, 11 people resc...
NewsChannel 3-1211 people rescued after seaplane crashes off Washington coas...
The IndependentSeaplane bursts into flames after crashing off US coast
WHMI 93.5 FMWHMI 93.5 FM Radio Station -- Livingston County Michigan
YahooSeaplane crashes, catches fire north of Seattle; all 11 on b...
CBS NewsSeaplane crashes, catches fire in Puget Sound area north of ...
The Times of IndiaWatch: Kenmore Air seaplane carrying 11 crashes near Washing...
The Financial Express'All flights cancelled': Kenmore Air seaplane with 11 people...
WalesOnlineHorror as plane crash lands on remote island and crews treat...
Agamir SomoyUSA: Seaplane engulfed in flames after emergency landing, al...
Yakima Herald-RepublicPlane crashes off Sucia Island in San Juans; 11 rescued
Internewscast JournalMultiple Injured as Floatplane Catches Fire After Emergency ...
The US SunMultiple injured after plane carrying 11 bursts into flames ...
Irish mirrorHorror 'fireball' plane crash on remote island as 11 people ...
The National Desk11 people rescued from fiery seaplane crash off coast of Was...
Bristol PostCrews rush to rescue 11 people after plane crash lands and e...
huddersfieldexaminerCrash plane explodes into fireball as mergency crews treat 1...
NewsweekSeaplane crashes in Washington state with 11 people on board...
Dublin LiveAll 11 passengers survive after plane crash lands on remote ...
Daily StarPlane crash lands into fireball on secluded island as all pa...
Daily RecordMiracle escape for passengers after explodes into fireball
Fox NewsMultiple injured after floatplane makes emergency landing, c...
Local News Now (WRGA AM)Multiple injured after floatplane makes emergency landing, c...
CNN International11 people rescued after seaplane crashes off Sucia Island
Channel 300011 people rescued after seaplane crashes off Washington coas...
WAAY TV 3111 people rescued after seaplane crashes off Washington coas...
Anadolu AjansıAll 11 rescued after Kenmore Air seaplane catches fire off W...
The Olympian10 passengers, one pilot accounted for after plane crash nea...
Hindustan TimesSeaplane makes emergency landing near Washington before catc...
BeritajaWashington Seaplane Crash Injures Multiple After Emergency L...
Economic TimesWATCH: Kenmore Air seaplane carrying 11 people crashes at Wa...
New York PostPlane with 11 on board bursts into flames after crash-landin...
Rolling OutWhy this Washington seaplane crash ended in relief
The OlympianFloatplane catches fire after emergency landing near Sucia I...
Belleville News-DemocratSeaplane carrying 11 people crashes near Washington's San Ju...
ABC NewsMultiple injured, 1 critically, after seaplane with 11 aboar...
YahooMultiple injured, 1 critically, after seaplane with 11 aboar...
My Bellingham Now -All 11 passengers accounted for following plane crash near S...
USA TodaySeaplane carrying 11 people crashes near Washington's San Ju...
YahooSeaplane carrying 11 people crashes near Washington's San Ju...
TimesNowScary Moments as Kenmore Air Plane Crashes Into Water Near S...
My NorthwestAt least 10 aboard plane crash in San Juan Islands - MyNorth...
KATUKenmore Air seaplane crashes near Sucia Island; all 11 aboar...
YahooKenmore plane crashes in San Juan Islands; no word on injuri...
ArcaMaxHow 11 Kenmore Air crash survivors were rescued off Washingt...
The JournalA seaplane carrying 11 crashes into an island north of Seatt...
The news, read by both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.