California Prosecutors Say They Will Continue Seeking Death Sentences After Newsom’s Commutations
|
The Facts
- Gov. Gavin Newsom announced plans to commute 548 California death sentences to life without parole.
- Newsom announced the commutations on Thursday.
- California law continues to allow capital punishment for murder.
- Some California prosecutors said they would continue seeking death sentences in future cases.
- California’s Supreme Court must review clemency for people convicted of more than one felony.
- Newsom imposed a moratorium on executions after taking office in 2019.
- California last executed a prisoner in 2006.
- Future death sentences could repopulate California’s death row if prosecutors seek them and future governors do not commute them.
Context
Will anyone be released under the commutation plan?
No. The plan changes death sentences to life in prison without the possibility of parole. TIME,Trent
Does the governor’s action abolish California’s death penalty?
No. California still permits capital punishment for murder, and prosecutors can continue to seek death sentences in new cases. NYT,Dnevnik
What remains unresolved?
The California Supreme Court must review clemency proceedings involving people with more than one felony conviction, and future governors could determine the fate of any new death sentences. NYT,vaticannews.va
Where Left and Right agree, and where they split
- Where Left and Right agree
- Newsom's commutations leave California's death penalty statute intact, meaning prosecutors can still seek new death sentences and refill death row if future governors don't intervene.
- Where Left and Right split
- The left and the right split on whether mass clemency ends executions or just overrides the law.
- Why they won’t converge
- The divide is one of values: the left treats capital punishment itself as illegitimate and wants the law abolished, while the right accepts the law's legitimacy and insists clemency should track individual case merit, not blanket policy.
How left and right read it
A punishment unused since 2006, and formally paused since 2019, is one California can no longer justify handing down—so commuting 548 death sentences to life without parole marks a genuine turning point in this country's history with executions. Yet some prosecutors say they will keep seeking new death sentences, meaning the row could refill. The law itself should go.
“Gavin Newsom's decision to empty his state's death row is a truly remarkable moment in the US's death penalty history.” — The Guardian
Five hundred forty-eight death sentences erased in a single Thursday announcement, while California law continues to allow capital punishment for murder. That is clemency wielded to void a penalty the statute still authorizes rather than to correct a particular injustice — so prosecutors are right to keep seeking death sentences in the cases that warrant them. Clemency involving multiple felonies must pass the state Supreme Court. Who checks the rest?
“If these commutations survive legal challenge, they will mark an extreme and cynical abuse of power.” — New York Post
Mass clemency clears death row today, but the statute leaves the door open for prosecutors to refill it tomorrow.
The receipts — 94 sources
Wire services (2)
Independent coverage (92)
The news, read by both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.