Sam Altman testifies in Oakland trial over Elon Musk’s lawsuit against OpenAI
The facts
- Sam Altman testified in federal court in Oakland, California, during the third week of the trial over Elon Musk’s lawsuit against OpenAI.
- Musk’s lawsuit alleges that OpenAI and its leaders moved away from the organization’s original nonprofit mission by shifting toward a for-profit or commercial structure.
- Altman testified that Musk had supported OpenAI becoming a for-profit business, disputing Musk’s claim that the company’s commercial shift was a betrayal of its founding purpose.
- Altman said Musk sought greater control over OpenAI in its early years, including asking for a dominant stake or other forms of control.
- Altman told the court that Musk at one point said control of OpenAI could pass to his children, which Altman presented as evidence that Musk wanted long-term control of the company.
- The trial also involves scrutiny of Microsoft’s relationship with OpenAI, with testimony from Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella about the company’s investment and role as a major backer.
- What remains unresolved is whether the court will accept Musk’s argument that OpenAI’s restructuring violated its founding commitments or OpenAI’s argument that the shift was consistent with plans discussed early on.
Context
What is Musk accusing OpenAI of doing?
Musk argues that OpenAI abandoned the nonprofit mission it was founded with and used his roughly $38 million in support for commercial purposes he says were not authorized NYT,CNBC,News18.
What was Altman’s main response on the witness stand?
Altman denied that OpenAI’s leaders stole from or misused a charity and said Musk had himself backed a for-profit structure while also trying to gain more control over the company NYT,BBC,MoneyControl.
Why is Microsoft part of the story?
Microsoft is a defendant in the case and a major OpenAI investor, so the trial is examining how much influence it had over OpenAI’s direction and whether that relationship shaped the company’s move toward a commercial model NYT,Indian Express,infobae.
Common ground, and where they split
- Common ground
- OpenAI’s shift toward a commercial structure is being tested not just as a business decision but as a question of whether the organization remained faithful to the commitments and governance terms that underwrote its original mission.
- Where Left and Right split
- Whether the story is mainly about public accountability when a mission-driven institution commercializes, or about procedural legitimacy and who had the right to shape OpenAI’s governance under plans discussed from the start.
How left and right read it
What stands out is a governance fight over whether an organization founded around a nonprofit mission can move toward a commercial structure without losing the commitments that justified its influence in the first place. With Microsoft’s role also under scrutiny and the court still weighing whether the restructuring violated those founding commitments, the public-interest question is who this institution is ultimately accountable to.
The central issue is procedural legitimacy: whether OpenAI’s restructuring was consistent with plans discussed early on, or whether it broke the terms Musk says mattered at the start. Altman’s testimony that Musk supported a for-profit model and sought dominant control cuts both ways, because it suggests this case is as much about who gets to govern the organization as about the wisdom of commercialization itself.
The receipts — 88 sources
Wire services (1)
Other coverage (87)
A news briefing built to show both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.