Senate Confirms Dr. Erica Schwartz as CDC Director in 51-44 Vote
The Facts
- The Senate confirmed Dr. Erica Schwartz as director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention on Wednesday by a vote of 51-44.
- The vote fell mostly along party lines, with Sen. Tim Kaine of Virginia the only Democrat to vote in favor.
- Schwartz becomes the CDC's first Senate-confirmed, permanent director in roughly a year; the agency has been led by acting directors since August 2025, most recently NIH Director Jay Bhattacharya.
- She succeeds Susan Monarez, whom Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. fired 29 days into the job amid a clash over vaccine policy.
- Schwartz is the Trump administration's third nominee to lead the CDC; the first, former Florida Rep. David Weldon, was withdrawn by the White House in March 2025 shortly before his confirmation hearing.
- Schwartz, 54, holds medical and law degrees, served as a deputy surgeon general during Trump's first term, worked as a Navy physician and held a senior medical role at the U.S. Coast Guard; she becomes the 22nd leader of the CDC.
- Schwartz has publicly affirmed the safety and efficacy of childhood vaccines, distinguishing her from other health officials in the administration and from earlier candidates for the job.
- Her confirmation leaves unresolved whether she will preserve the agency's scientific independence under Kennedy; at a Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee hearing, Chairman Bill Cassidy and other senators questioned whether she would challenge Kennedy if directed to act against the evidence.
- Schwartz takes over an agency facing the worst U.S. measles resurgence in three decades, linked to falling childhood immunization rates, an Ebola outbreak in the Democratic Republic of Congo and Uganda, and a multistate foodborne illness outbreak involving Cyclospora tied to contaminated lettuce.
Context
Why has the CDC been without a confirmed director for nearly a year?
Trump's first nominee, former Rep. David Weldon, was withdrawn in March 2025 just before his confirmation hearing Guardian,USA Today. His second, Susan Monarez, was confirmed but fired by Kennedy in late August 2025 after 29 days over a dispute on vaccine policy U.S. News & World R…,NBC News,CBS News. Monarez later told senators Kennedy had asked her to commit to firing CDC experts and to preapprove new vaccine guidelines without review, and that she refused Atlanta Journal-Con…. Acting directors ran the agency in the interim, most recently NIH Director Jay Bhattacharya, who had served since February Investing.com,NBC News.
What was the main issue senators raised about Schwartz?
Her nomination looked uncertain after a July hearing before the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee, where Chairman Bill Cassidy, R-La., and others pressed her on whether she would push back against Kennedy if he ordered actions she believed were not supported by evidence U.S. News & World R…,Investing.com. That question — whether she can maintain the CDC's scientific independence under Kennedy — remained unresolved at the time of the vote Washington Post.
What is on her agenda when she takes office?
Sources report she inherits an agency dealing with the worst U.S. measles resurgence in about 30 years, attributed to declining childhood immunization rates, an international Ebola outbreak in the Democratic Republic of Congo and Uganda, and a large foodborne illness outbreak involving the Cyclospora parasite linked to contaminated lettuce Aol,NY Post,India Today,Fox News. AP reporting also describes the agency as affected by political interference and low staff morale Eagle-Tribune.
Where Left and Right agree, and where they split
- Where Left and Right agree
- A year of acting leadership at the CDC, following a confirmed director fired 29 days in over vaccine policy, is treated by both reads as a real institutional failure now ended.
- Where Left and Right split
- A director who must hold the line on vaccine evidence against Kennedy, or an agency finally answerable to someone the Senate actually confirmed.
How left and right read it
A public health agency left to acting leadership for roughly a year, after its last confirmed director was fired 29 days in over vaccine policy, is not a bureaucratic footnote — it is the institution families rely on to say plainly that childhood vaccines are safe and effective. Schwartz has said so, and senators pressed her on whether she would hold that line under Kennedy. That commitment, backed by evidence rather than deference, is the minimum the public is owed — especially with hesitancy rising.
“Schwartz will also have to contend with rising rates of vaccine hesitancy, which some experts say Kennedy's rhetoric and policies have exacerbated.” — NBC News
The Senate confirmed Erica Schwartz 51-44, ending roughly a year in which the CDC ran on acting directors after Kennedy fired Susan Monarez 29 days in. Schwartz brings medical and law degrees, a deputy surgeon general's tenure, and Navy and Coast Guard service — plus something no caretaker holds: a confirmation vote she answers for. Acting leadership is borrowed authority. Confirm qualified nominees; stop running agencies on placeholders.
“Schwartz is the latest person to lead the agency during Trump's second term in a position that has seen nearly a half dozen different names and faces helming the nation's disease-fighting outfit.” — Fox News
The receipts — 91 sources
Wire services (15)
Independent coverage (76)
The news, read by both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.