US Supreme Court strikes down most Trump emergency tariffs, prompting global reactions and legal uncertainty
The facts
- The US Supreme Court ruled by a 6–3 majority that President Donald Trump exceeded his authority by using the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) to impose broad tariffs.
- The Court’s decision invalidated most of Trump’s wide-ranging global or 'reciprocal' tariffs imposed on many countries, while leaving in place certain sector-specific tariffs such as those on steel and aluminum.
- The ruling held that the IEEPA, a law intended for national emergencies, does not provide clear congressional authorization for the president to unilaterally impose tariffs of unlimited scope, amount, and duration.
- The case arose from lawsuits brought by companies and a group of US states arguing that Trump’s use of IEEPA to levy broad import taxes without Congress was unprecedented and unlawful.
- The Supreme Court did not decide how already collected tariffs should be handled, instead leaving questions about potential refunds and implementation to lower courts such as the Court of International Trade.
- Analyses cited in coverage estimate that more than $175 billion in tariff revenue collected under Trump’s emergency-based tariffs could be subject to refund claims following the ruling.
- In public remarks after the decision, Trump called the ruling deeply or profoundly disappointing, criticized the justices who voted against his position, and said he was ashamed of some members of the Court.
- Following the Supreme Court defeat, Trump announced and then signed an order imposing a new 10% global tariff on imports under Section 122 of the 1974 Trade Act, which allows temporary tariffs of up to 15% for up to 150 days unless extended by Congress.
- Major US trading partners including the European Union, United Kingdom, Canada, and Mexico have said they are studying the Supreme Court decision and its implications for existing and future US tariffs.
Context
Which Trump tariffs did the Supreme Court strike down, and which remain in place?
The Court struck down the broad global or 'reciprocal' tariffs Trump imposed on dozens of countries by invoking the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA), ruling that he lacked authority to use that emergency law for such wide-ranging import duties.BBC,BBC,infobae,infobae,QQ新闻中心,WEB.DE,WEB.DE,N-tv However, sector-specific tariffs that were based on other trade statutes—such as those on steel and aluminum—were not directly affected by this decision and currently remain in force.BBC,infobae,T-online.de,QQ新闻中心,WEB.DE,N-tv
Why did the Supreme Court say Trump’s use of emergency powers for tariffs was unlawful?
The majority held that the International Emergency Economic Powers Act, designed for national emergencies, does not clearly authorize a president to unilaterally impose tariffs of unlimited scope, amount, and duration, and that such taxing authority belongs primarily to Congress under the US Constitution.BBC,infobae,infobae,QQ新闻中心,WEB.DE,WEB.DE,as,N-tv The justices concluded that Trump’s attempt to rely on IEEPA to enact sweeping tariffs overstepped the statutory and constitutional limits on presidential power in trade policy.BBC,infobae,infobae,QQ新闻中心,WEB.DE,WEB.DE,as,N-tv
What are the immediate economic and legal consequences of the ruling?
The decision creates legal uncertainty over more than $175 billion in tariffs collected under Trump’s emergency-based measures, with lower courts expected to handle potential refund claims and implementation details.infobae,infobae,QQ新闻中心,N-tv It also triggered a rapid policy response from the White House, as Trump moved to impose a new temporary 10% global tariff under a different law, while foreign governments and businesses assess how the ruling and new tariffs will affect trade flows and existing agreements.La Repubblica,infobae,infobae,infobae,infobae,T-online.de,QQ新闻中心,Bild,WEB.DE,WEB.DE,N-tv
The receipts — 100 sources
Other coverage (100)
A news briefing built to show both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.