Supreme Court set to hear Colorado Catholic preschool funding dispute
Rights & JusticeWell-coveredThe Facts
- The Supreme Court is scheduled to hear St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy on Nov. 3.
- Catholic parishes, the Archdiocese of Denver and parents challenged Colorado's preschool funding program.
- Colorado's Universal Preschool program funds 15 hours of weekly preschool for participating providers.
- Colorado requires participating preschool providers to comply with nondiscrimination rules.
- The Catholic plaintiffs seek a religious exemption from the program's enrollment condition.
- The dispute concerns whether religious preschools may refuse enrollment to children of gay or transgender parents.
- The Trump administration supports the Catholic groups in the case.
Context
What are the Catholic plaintiffs asking the court to decide?
They seek permission to participate in Colorado's Universal Preschool program without complying with its enrollment condition, which they say conflicts with their religious beliefs. U.S. News & World R… Jerusalem Post EconoTimes
What is Colorado's position?
Colorado officials argue that participating preschools must follow the program's nondiscrimination requirement; officials have said the Catholic schools are seeking permission to discriminate against 4-year-olds. U.S. News & World R… Jerusalem Post Public Radio Tulsa
Why could the case matter beyond the parties?
The ruling could define whether religious preschool providers can receive public funding while seeking exemptions from enrollment rules that apply to other program participants. U.S. News & World R… Public Radio Tulsa EconoTimes
Where Left and Right agree, and where they split
- Where Left and Right agree
- Colorado's preschool funding is conditioned on nondiscrimination rules the Catholic parishes say conflict with their faith, and both sides agree someone must justify that condition.
- Where Left and Right split
- The left and right split on who must justify Colorado's enrollment condition: the parishes or the state.
- Why they won’t converge
- The two sides disagree on where the burden of proof should sit in church-state funding disputes, a values-based divide over religious liberty versus equal access that survives any agreement on the facts.
How left and right read it
The exemption sought by the Catholic parishes and the Denver archdiocese would let a publicly funded seat be denied to a child because her parents are gay or transgender, a position the Trump administration now backs. The burden belongs on those asking to be excused.
A benefit offered universally stops being universal the moment the state prices it in doctrine. Colorado funds 15 hours of weekly preschool for participating providers, yet it conditions that participation on enrollment rules the parishes and the Archdiocese of Denver say their faith will not let them adopt — so the state, not the church, should have to justify the condition. Let families keep both the seat and the parish.
A preschool seat comes with a nondiscrimination string attached. The real fight is over who must justify that string: the state or the parishes refusing it.
The receipts — 7 sources
Wire services (2)
Independent coverage (5)
The news, read by both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.