Supreme Court sends North Dakota and Mississippi Voting Rights Act cases back to lower courts
The facts
- The Supreme Court sent voting-rights cases from North Dakota and Mississippi back to lower courts for reconsideration.
- The court directed the lower courts to reconsider those cases in light of its recent ruling in Louisiana v. Callais.
- One issue in the cases is whether private individuals and advocacy groups, rather than only the federal government, can sue to enforce Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act.
- In the North Dakota case, the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals had ruled that only the federal government can sue to enforce Section 2.
- The North Dakota case was brought by two Native American tribes and concerns claims that district lines diluted Native American voting strength.
- The question of who can sue matters because private plaintiffs and advocacy groups have brought most Section 2 lawsuits, so limits on private suits could narrow enforcement of the law.
- Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson dissented from the Supreme Court’s decision to send the cases back rather than resolve the enforcement question.
Context
What is Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act?
Section 2 is the provision of the Voting Rights Act that prohibits discriminatory voting practices, including redistricting plans alleged to dilute minority voting strength CBS News,UPI.
Why is the North Dakota case receiving so much attention?
The case tests whether voters and advocacy groups can continue bringing Section 2 lawsuits. That issue is closely watched because private plaintiffs have filed most of those cases, so restricting them to the Justice Department could reduce one of the main ways the law is enforced Aol,CBS News,CNN International.
Did the Supreme Court decide who can sue under Section 2?
No. The court sent the cases back for further review after Louisiana v. Callais instead of definitively resolving whether private parties may sue under Section 2 NPR,CNN International,Court House News Se….
Common ground, and where they split
- Common ground
- Sending the cases back leaves unresolved who may enforce Section 2, a question with major real-world consequences because most such lawsuits have been brought by private plaintiffs and advocacy groups and limits on those suits could sharply narrow the law’s reach.
- Where Left and Right split
- Less a disagreement than a question of emphasis: the immediate risk to Native American and other minority voters if private suits are curtailed, versus the court’s choice to proceed through reconsideration in light of Louisiana v. Callais rather than settle the enforcement question now.
How left and right read it
What stands out here is the practical threat to voting-rights enforcement: the cases were sent back without resolving whether private individuals and advocacy groups can sue under Section 2, even though most Section 2 lawsuits have come from those plaintiffs. That matters especially in the North Dakota case, where two Native American tribes say district lines diluted Native American voting strength and the 8th Circuit had already limited enforcement to the federal government.
The notable point here is institutional restraint: the Supreme Court sent the North Dakota and Mississippi cases back for reconsideration in light of Louisiana v. Callais rather than immediately settling who may sue under Section 2. That matters because the 8th Circuit said only the federal government can enforce Section 2, while limits on private suits could significantly narrow how the law is enforced.
The receipts — 31 sources
Wire services (12)
Other coverage (19)
A news briefing built to show both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.