Supreme Court to Hear Exxon and Suncor Bid to Block Boulder Climate Lawsuit
The facts
- The U.S. Supreme Court has agreed to hear an appeal by Exxon Mobil and Suncor Energy in a climate lawsuit brought by the city and county of Boulder, Colorado.
- The Boulder lawsuit alleges that Exxon and Suncor violated state law by misleading or deceiving the public about how fossil fuels contribute to climate change and seeks monetary damages for climate-related harms.
- The Supreme Court will review a May 2025 Colorado Supreme Court ruling that allowed Boulder’s case to proceed in state court under state law.
- Exxon and Suncor are asking the Supreme Court to decide whether federal law prevents or preempts state-law claims for climate-related injuries, arguing that issues involving greenhouse gas emissions should be governed by federal law.
- The Supreme Court’s decision in the Boulder case could affect dozens of similar climate-related lawsuits filed by cities, counties, and states across the United States seeking billions of dollars in damages from fossil fuel companies.
- Many of the climate lawsuits brought by governments around the country seek compensation to help pay for rebuilding and mitigation related to wildfires, rising sea levels, floods, and severe storms that they say are worsened by climate change.
- The Supreme Court has a conservative majority and has previously declined to take up similar climate liability disputes before agreeing to hear the Boulder case.
- Arguments in the case are expected to be heard during the Supreme Court term that begins in October.
Context
What is Boulder alleging in its climate lawsuit against Exxon and Suncor?
Boulder’s lawsuit claims that Exxon Mobil and Suncor Energy violated Colorado state law by misleading or deceiving the public about the contribution of their fossil fuel products to climate change, including through marketing and public communications, and seeks monetary damages to cover local costs from climate-related impacts such as extreme temperatures, wildfires, floods, and other environmental harms NYT,Guardian,NBC News,Reuters,Fox Business,NewsMax,Fortune.
What legal question is the Supreme Court being asked to decide in this case?
The Supreme Court is being asked to decide whether federal law preempts or bars state-law claims seeking to hold fossil fuel companies liable for climate-related harms, including whether disputes over greenhouse gas emissions and global climate change must be handled under federal law and in federal courts rather than under state consumer protection and tort laws in state courts USA Today,Reuters,Hill,Hill,Fox Business,Axios,Fortune,Los Angeles Times.
Why does this case matter for other climate lawsuits around the country?
Because dozens of cities, counties, and states have filed similar lawsuits seeking billions of dollars from fossil fuel companies for climate-related damages, the Supreme Court’s ruling on whether such claims can proceed under state law in state courts—or must be governed by federal law—could determine whether many of these cases move forward or are effectively shut down, shaping the broader strategy of climate accountability litigation in the United States Fast Company,NYT,NBC News,CBS News,Reuters,Bloomberg Business,Axios,Euronews English,Fortune,Los Angeles Times,Los Angeles Times.
The receipts — 85 sources
Wire services (14)
Other coverage (71)
A news briefing built to show both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.