Trump Orders Navy to Replace Electromagnetic Catapults With Steam on Future Carriers, Opens Warship Building to Foreign Shipyards
The facts
- Trump signed a national security memorandum on Thursday ordering the Navy to replace electromagnetic catapults with steam catapults on future carriers.
- The memorandum gives the Pentagon and Navy 60 days to submit a plan for the change.
- The future USS Doris Miller, the fourth Ford-class carrier, is the first ship to be redesigned.
- The USS Gerald R. Ford, USS John F. Kennedy and USS Enterprise will keep their electromagnetic systems.
- The memo also directs replacement of the Ford class's electromagnetic weapons elevators.
- The same memorandum opens U.S. warship construction to foreign shipyards for the first time in decades.
- Reporting differs on cost: some accounts cite hundreds of millions of dollars, others billions.
- Many Navy officers have opposed abandoning the electromagnetic launch system, according to multiple outlets.
- Huntington Ingalls is the primary contractor building Ford-class aircraft carriers.
Context
What is EMALS, and how does it differ from steam catapults?
The Electromagnetic Aircraft Launch System uses magnetic force rather than steam pressure to launch jets from a carrier deck U.S. News & World R…,India Today. Reporting describes EMALS as requiring fewer sailors to operate and being easier to maintain than steam catapults, while allowing higher launch speeds U.S. News & World R…,Hindustan Times,Euronews English. The Navy has also struggled with reliability problems on the first ship of the class SCMP.
Why is Trump making this change now?
Trump has criticized the electromagnetic system since at least 2017, when he described the idea in a Time magazine interview, arguing the system is more expensive and less effective than steam Guardian,Raw Story,Reuters. In the memo he wrote that the Pentagon 'shall restore both capacity and competition to the maritime industrial base' using 'proven, reliable' technology Hill.
What remains unresolved?
The final cost is unclear, with estimates in reporting ranging from hundreds of millions to billions of dollars Aol,WSJ,Handelsblatt. Hegseth and acting Navy Secretary Hung Cao must still produce the implementation plan within 60 days, which will determine the technical scope of the redesign Guardian,TimesNow.
Common ground, and where they split
- Common ground
- The order overrides years of uniformed objection at a price no one has pinned down — somewhere between hundreds of millions and billions — and neither framing disputes either point.
- Where Left and Right split
- Billions committed on one man's preference over the officers who know the systems, or an elected commander in chief exercising authority he alone answers for.
How left and right read it
Billions in public money can now be committed on the strength of one man's long-running preference, and that is the stake: reporting cannot even agree whether swapping electromagnetic catapults for steam costs hundreds of millions or billions, yet the Navy officers who objected for years get 60 days to draft the plan anyway. The same memo hands warship construction to foreign yards. Whose judgment governs the fleet?
“Donald Trump has ordered the US Navy to return to using old steam catapults to launch fighter jets, in a move that has been a bizarre obsession for the President in recent years.” — The Independent
Command of the fleet belongs to the elected commander in chief, not to the officers who spent years opposing abandonment of the electromagnetic launch system. So ordering steam catapults on the future Doris Miller — a plan due in 60 days, with three carriers keeping their current systems — sits squarely within that authority, and the price, whether hundreds of millions or billions, sits with him. He owns it.
“Sen. Mark Kelly (D-AZ) on Thursday tore into President Donald Trump for reportedly signing a memorandum directing the Navy to switch fighter jet launch systems aboard aircraft carriers, a move that is likely to come with a hefty paycheck.” — Washington Examiner
The receipts — 71 sources
Wire services (7)
Other coverage (64)
A news briefing built to show both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.