Trump withdraws Rudofsky appeals court nomination and selects Cody Hiland
The facts
- Trump withdrew Lee Rudofsky’s nomination to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit.
- Trump nominated Arkansas Supreme Court Justice J. Cody Hiland for the Eighth Circuit seat.
- Rudofsky is a U.S. district judge based in Arkansas.
- Arkansas Republican Sens. John Boozman and Tom Cotton opposed Rudofsky’s elevation to the Eighth Circuit.
- Boozman and Cotton preferred Hiland for the Eighth Circuit vacancy.
- The Eighth Circuit seat is being vacated by Judge Bobby E. Shepherd.
- Senate Republicans were seeking to confirm judges before Democrats take control of the Senate in January.
Context
Why was Rudofsky’s nomination withdrawn?
Arkansas Republican Sens. John Boozman and Tom Cotton opposed Rudofsky’s nomination and preferred Cody Hiland, making Senate confirmation uncertain. Washington Examiner news.bloomberglaw.c… Economic Times
Who is Cody Hiland?
Hiland is an Arkansas Supreme Court justice who was appointed by Gov. Sarah Huckabee Sanders in 2023 and elected to a full term in 2026. Arkansas Times Hot Springs Village…
Why does the timing matter?
The nomination comes as the White House and Senate Republicans seek to confirm judges before Democrats assume control of the Senate in January. Economic Times Edge Malaysia Taylorville Daily N…
Common ground, and where they split
- Common ground
- Rudofsky was swapped for Hiland specifically because Boozman and Cotton preferred Hiland, timed to the Senate's pre-January confirmation push.
- Where Left and Right split
- Whether the substitution is a rushed swap that bypassed real vetting, or an overdue deference to home-state senators' judgment about who belongs on their circuit.
- Why they differ
- The divide is about trust in institutional process: one reading treats home-state senator preference as a legitimate check worth deferring to, the other treats a mid-process swap as evidence the vetting process itself is being bent to a deadline.
How left and right read it
A lifetime seat on a federal appeals court should be earned through scrutiny, not slotted in against a clock. Yet Rudofsky's nomination was pulled and Hiland's substituted after Boozman and Cotton opposed the first and preferred the second, while Senate Republicans work to confirm judges before Democrats take control in January. That is a swap, not a vetting. Slow down and make the case for Hiland on the merits.
A seat on the Eighth Circuit is Arkansas's as much as Washington's, which is why Boozman and Cotton's judgment that Hiland, not Rudofsky, belongs in Shepherd's chair deserves real weight rather than polite dismissal. The President heard them and acted. With Senate Republicans working to confirm judges before Democrats take control in January, the question is simple: why would a majority stall a nominee its own members asked for?
The receipts — 11 sources
Wire services (1)
Other coverage (10)
A news briefing built to show both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.