Trump says he may consider reducing U.S. troop deployments in Italy and Spain after raising a similar possibility for Germany
The Facts
- Trump said he would probably consider reducing or withdrawing U.S. troops from Italy and Spain when asked about those deployments on April 30.
- Trump's comments on Italy and Spain came a day after he said the United States was reviewing a possible reduction of U.S. troops in Germany.
- Trump tied his criticism of European allies to their response to the Iran conflict, including complaints that NATO allies did not send naval support to help reopen the Strait of Hormuz.
- Italy, Spain, and Germany are all NATO members, so Trump's remarks widened a dispute between Washington and allied governments that host U.S. forces.
- The possibility of troop reductions remains unresolved: Trump said a decision on Germany would come in a short period of time, but the cited reports do not describe any formal withdrawal order for Germany, Italy, or Spain.
- The issue has broader alliance implications because Reuters and other outlets reported that Trump has also said he is considering withdrawing the United States from NATO, while a Pentagon email outlined options to penalize allies seen as not supporting U.S. operations against Iran.
Context
What exactly did Trump say about Italy and Spain?
Asked whether he would consider pulling U.S. troops out of Italy and Spain, Trump replied "probably" and said he was dissatisfied with those countries' support for the United States during the Iran conflict Aol,NDTV,News18.
Why are Italy and Spain part of this dispute?
The cited reports say Trump has criticized NATO allies for not helping reopen the Strait of Hormuz and has linked possible troop cuts to what he sees as insufficient support from European partners during the war with Iran Aol,Guardian,La Nacion.
What is still unknown?
It is not yet clear whether any troop reductions will actually happen, how large they would be, or when they would take effect. The reports say Trump raised the possibility for Germany, Italy, and Spain, but they do not describe a finalized policy or signed order Aol,NDTV,News18.
How left and right read it
Left says
What stands out is how much uncertainty this creates around an alliance structure that includes countries hosting U.S. forces, with no formal withdrawal order yet but a widening dispute across Italy, Spain, and Germany. When troop deployments and even possible U.S. withdrawal from NATO are raised alongside complaints about allied support, the risk is broader instability inside the alliance itself.
Is this how the left would actually put it?
Right says
The core issue is burden-sharing and whether allies are backing U.S. operations when it counts. Trump explicitly tied possible troop reductions to European allies’ response to the Iran conflict, including the lack of naval support to help reopen the Strait of Hormuz, and the unresolved status of any withdrawal keeps pressure on allies to show they are contributing.
Is this how the right would actually put it?
The receipts — 100 sources
Wire services (4)
Independent coverage (96)
LaSextaRobles responde a Trump y dice que sus amenazas de retirar l...
The GuardianTrump threatens to withdraw troops from Italy and Spain
Deutsche WelleТрамп не исключает вывод войск США из Италии и Испании
The IndependentNow Trump threatens to withdraw US troops from Italy and 'ho...
kp.ruПентагон ошеломлен: как Трамп поставил на уши представителей...
Московский КомсомолецПентагон напуган решением Трампа вывести войска из Германии
Quotidiano LiberoDonald Trump, "riduco i soldati Usa in Italia". La risposta ...
El UniversalTrump amaga con retirar sus tropas de España e Italia | El ...
Deutsche WelleТрамп погрожує вивести війська США з трьох європейських краї
The GuardianTrump threatens to withdraw US troops from Italy and Spain -...
URA.RUВ Пентагоне ошеломлены словами Трампа о выводе войск из Герм...
УНІАН"Вели себя ужасно": Трамп угрожает вывести войска еще из дву...
El EspañolÚltima hora política, en directo | El Gobierno se mantiene p...
7sur7Après l'Allemagne, Trump envisage de réduire ses troupes dan...
unian"Поводилися жахливо": Трамп погрожує вивести війська ще з дв...
MARCADonald Trump amenaza con retirar las tropas de España: "Ha s...
Euronews EnglishTrump considers troop cuts in Spain and Italy over Iran war ...
News18'Why Shouldn't I?' Trump Says US Considering Reducing Troops...
kp.ru"Политика угроз достигла своего предела": в Пентагоне шокиро...
Українська правдаЗаявление Трампа о сокращении войск США в Германии шокировал...
Lenta.ruРаскрыта реакция Пентагона на заявление Трампа о выводе войс...
BFMTVL'Italie d'"aucune aide" et l'Espagne "odieuse": après l'All...
EL IMPARCIAL | Noticias de México y el mundoTrump amenaza con tomar decisiones militares sobre España, I...
SabahSON DAKİKA... ABD/İsrail-İran Savaşı'nda gerilim zirvede! Tr...
El ConfidencialGuerra de Irán contra EEUU e Israel: última hora de Donald T...
Hindustan Times'Yeah, probably': Trump floats reducing US forces in Spain, ...
ТСН.uaСША можуть вивести війська з Італії та Іспанії: Трамп розкри...
BreitbartBlumenthal: Trump Is Threatening NATO Like a 'Five Year Old'
Business StandardTrump signals openness to reducing US troops in Spain, Italy...
ТСН.uaСША могут вывести войска из Италии и Испании: Трамп раскрити...
N-tvNach Drohung gegen Deutschland: Trump bringt US-Truppenabzug...
The GuardianTrump news at a glance: president doubles down on rift with ...
Українська правдаТрамп допускає виведення американських військ з Італії та Іс...
Українська правдаТрамп допускает вывод американских войск из Италии и Испании
En Son HaberABD Başkanı Trump: İran anlaşma yapmak için can atıyor - ens...
경향신문Trump "May also reduce U.S. troops in Italy·Spain... no help...
Le Parisien" L'Italie ne nous a apporté aucune aide et l'Espagne a été ...
Ouest FranceAprès l'Allemagne, Donald Trump dit envisager une réduction ...
NovostiАмеричка војска се повлачи из ове две земље? Трамп допусти м...
kp.ru"Угрозы достигли предела": в Германии раскритиковали Трампа ...
ANSA.itTrump: 'L'Italia non è stata d'aiuto, probabile il ritiro de...
lastampa.itTrump contro l'Italia: "Probabile il ritiro delle truppe Usa...
ZEIT ONLINEUSA: Donald Trump erwägt Truppenabzug auch aus Italien und S...
El FinancieroTrump advierte con retirar sus tropas de España e Italia por...
Sözcü GazetesiTrump: İran bizimle anlaşma yapmak için can atıyor - Sözcü G...
La NacionTrump dice que "probablemente" podría retirar las tropas de ...
ANSA.itTrump: 'L'Italia non è stata d'aiuto, probabile il ritiro de...
Московский КомсомолецТрамп дожал союзников: Германия указала Белому дому на дверь
TVA NouvellesAprès l'Allemagne, Trump envisage de réduire les troupes en ...
Lenta.ruВ Германии отреагировали на угрозы Трампа вывести войска
Українська правдаTrump: War in Ukraine continues because "Biden gave them US$...
Correio da ManhaTrump ameaça retirar tropas de Espanha e Itália devido à pos...
Notícias ao MinutoTrump ameaça tirar tropas de Espanha e Itália devido à postu...
CumhuriyetTrump'ın iddiası: 'İran bir anlaşma yapmak için can atıyor'
HaberlerTrump: İran'a yönelik deniz ablukası devam edecek
OpenTrump: "L'Italia non è stata d'aiuto, probabilmente valuto u...
HaberlerTrump: "İran bir anlaşma yapmak için can atıyor"
Il MessaggeroBasi Usa in Italia, quante sono e dove si trovano: da Sigone...
www.kleinezeitung.atUS-Truppenabzug auch aus Italien und Spanien vorstellbar
RTVE.esTrump advierte que podría retirar sus tropas de España e Ita...
Il MessaggeroBasi Usa in Italia, quante sono e dove si trovano: da Sigone...
Yeni Akit GazetesiTrump'tan ilginç İran açıklaması: Can atıyorlar
HaberlerABD Başkanı Trump: "İran bizimle anlaşma yapmak için can atı...
EL MUNDOTrump asegura que podría retirar sus tropas de España e Ital...
HERALDOTrump advierte que podría retirar sus tropas de España e Ita...
The Straits TimesTrump says 'probably' when asked if he might pull US troops ...
MilliyetTrump, İspanya ve İtalya'daki ABD askerlerini çekmeyi değerl...
Аргументы и фактыТрамп допустил возможность вывода военных сил США из Испании...
NDTVAfter Germany, Trump Says US Considering Reducing Troops In ...
LaSextaTrump dice que podría retirar sus tropas de España e Italia ...
HaberlerTrump, Almanya'nın ardından İspanya ve İtalya'daki ABD asker...
Il Fatto QuotidianoTrump minaccia ritiro truppe da Italia, Spagna e Germania | ...
РБК-УкраинаТрамп пригрозил вывести войска США еще из двух стран Европы
kp.ruСША хотят сократить численность своих войск еще в нескольких...
Libertad DigitalTrump amenaza con retirar sus tropas de España por su postur...
Der Tagesspiegel"Sie waren keine Hilfe": Trump hält US-Truppenabzug auch aus...
QuotidianoNetTrump vuole ritirare i soldati Usa dall'Italia: "Non è stata...
ANSA.itTrump: 'L'Italia non è stata d'aiuto, probabile il ritiro de...
Yahoo NewsTrump mulls US troop cuts in Italy, Spain over Iran row
Interfax.ruТрамп не исключил, что может вывести часть войск США из Итал...
watson.ch/Trump: US-Truppenabzug auch aus Italien und Spanien vorstell...
RTVE.esTrump estudia reducir las tropas estadounidenses en Alemania...
Notícias ao MinutoChanceler alemão defende "parceria transatlântica fiável" co...
Lenta.ruТрамп обвинил НАТО в "бардаке" на Украине
ANSA.itTrump, possibile la riduzione delle truppe Usa in Italia e S...
il Giornale.itDonald Trump ancora all'attacco: "L'Italia non è stata di ne...
Lenta.ruТрамп пригрозил выводом войск США из двух стран НАТО
El ConfidencialTrump dice que podría retirar sus tropas de España e Italia ...
France 24Trump sopesa reducir tropas de EE. UU. en Alemania: ¿qué pro...
stern.de"Völlig wirkungslos" im Ukraine-Krieg: Trump ätzt gegen Merz
ElNacional.catTrump esbronca Merz per les seves crítiques a la guerra de l...
IndexHRTrump napao Merza
El FinancieroTrump amenaza con retirar su Ejército de Alemania... y Berlí...
EL MUNDOAlemania toma nota de la amenaza de Donald Trump de recortar...
IndexHRTrump prijeti Njemačkoj, stigao odgovor Merza
La Voz de GaliciaTrump estudiará una posible reducción de tropas estadouniden...
The news, read by both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.