Fifth Circuit finds House proxy voting unconstitutional in 2022 spending bill vote
The facts
- The Fifth Circuit ruled 9-8 that House proxy voting used for the 2022 spending bill was unconstitutional.
- The ruling concerned a $1.7 trillion government funding bill passed by the House in 2022.
- The court upheld an injunction blocking the bill’s pregnant-worker accommodation provision.
- The provision required employers to provide workplace accommodations for pregnant workers.
- The injunction applies in Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi.
- The decision could prompt challenges to other laws enacted using the House’s proxy-voting rule.
- The ruling is expected to be appealed to the Supreme Court.
Context
What was the House proxy-voting rule?
The House adopted the pandemic-era rule in 2020, allowing members to cast votes or be counted for quorum purposes through another member rather than being physically present. Washington Post NBC News Reason
What workplace protections are affected?
The provision required workplace accommodations for pregnant workers, including breaks, limits on heavy lifting and time for prenatal appointments. NYT
Common ground, and where they split
- Common ground
- The proxy-voting ruling carries real consequence, not mere procedural trivia: it already blocks the enacted pregnant-worker protections in three states and threatens other laws passed the same way.
- Where Left and Right split
- The left and the right split on whether a pregnant-worker protection or a voting procedure deserves priority.
- Why they differ
- The split is over trust in institutional process versus outcomes: one reading treats procedural compliance as the thing that legitimizes any law, the other treats the accommodation itself as the measure of legitimacy regardless of how it passed.
- Watch for
- Watch for whether the Supreme Court takes up the expected appeal of the Fifth Circuit's 9-8 ruling, which would determine if the proxy-voting rationale holds beyond Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi.The New York Times, Washington Post
How left and right read it
A pregnant worker's right to a chair, a water bottle, a schedule change should not hinge on a procedural autopsy of how the House took attendance in 2022. Yet a 9-8 ruling declaring proxy voting unconstitutional now leaves that accommodation requirement blocked in Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi, with the same reasoning available against other laws passed under that rule. The appeal should restore what Congress enacted.
“The appellate court upheld Texas's injunction stopping accommodations for pregnant workers by targeting how Congress passed a massive Biden-era funding bill.” — Washington Post
How a law is made is not a technicality — it is the only thing that makes it binding. A $1.7 trillion funding bill moved through the House on proxy voting, and because the Fifth Circuit found that procedure unconstitutional, the pregnant-worker accommodation mandate it carried cannot be enforced in Texas, Louisiana or Mississippi. That reasoning now reaches other laws passed the same way. Congress must show up to legislate.
The fight isn't over pregnant workers' needs directly — it's over whether a proxy vote can validly pass the law protecting them.
The receipts — 19 sources
Other coverage (19)
A news briefing built to show both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.