Skip to content
ReframedNewsLeft · Right · Centered
Quick ReadArchiveAboutSign in
Briefing stories›Rights & Justice

Ninth Circuit judges rebuke colleague’s vulgar dissent in transgender discrimination case involving Washington spa

Story date · Friday, March 13, 2026Rights & JusticeWell-covered

The facts

  • The full Ninth Circuit declined to rehear (en banc) the Olympus Spa v. Armstrong case.
  • Judge Lawrence VanDyke wrote a dissent from the denial of rehearing that used the phrase “this is a case about swinging dicks.”
  • After VanDyke’s dissent, a large group of Ninth Circuit judges issued written rebukes/responses criticizing the dissent’s coarse or vulgar language.
  • The dispute involves Olympus Spa, described as a women-only Korean spa in Washington state, and its refusal to serve a transgender woman.
  • The spa argued that Washington state’s anti-discrimination law (and its enforcement) violated the spa’s constitutional rights.
  • VanDyke is an appointee of President Donald Trump.

Context

What was the court decision that prompted the dissent and rebukes?

The Ninth Circuit declined to rehear the case en banc, leaving in place earlier rulings that rejected the spa’s lawsuit challenging Washington’s anti-discrimination enforcement. Reuters,Talking Points Memo,Reason

What language drew criticism from other judges?

VanDyke’s dissent opened with the phrase “this is a case about swinging dicks,” which multiple reports describe as unusually crude for a judicial opinion and which triggered written responses from many colleagues. Reuters,Reason,news.bloomberglaw.c…

What is the underlying dispute about Olympus Spa?

The case centers on a women-only spa in Washington state and whether the state can enforce its anti-discrimination law in connection with the spa’s refusal of service to a transgender woman; the spa contended the enforcement violated its constitutional rights. Reuters,Talking Points Memo,news.bloomberglaw.c…

See this differently than someone you know would?

The receipts — 18 sources

Wire services (1)

ReutersReutersUS judges condemn Trump appointee's 'vulgar barroom talk' in...

Other coverage (17)

PolitiZoomStories From Late At Night
Twitchy'This Is a Case About Swinging D***s:' A Dissent Goes THERE ...
Raw StoryTrump-appointee delivers 'grotesque Supreme Court audition' ...
Redstate9th Circuit Judge Comes Out Swinging (Ahem)...in Spicy Disse...
SFist - San Francisco News, Restaurants, Events, & SportsNinth Circuit Judge, Who of Course Is a Trump Appointee, Iss...
HotAirAn Amusing Dissent to the 9th Circuit Has Progressive Judges...
The Daily Signal'Collectively Lost Their Minds': 9th Circuit Backs Access fo...
Slate MagazineWe Have a Winner for Most Grotesque Supreme Court Audition Y...
Above the Law'We Are Better Than This,' Say Ninth Circuit Judges Despite ...
TheBlaze'Case about swinging d**ks': Fed-up Trump judge tears apart ...
news.bloomberglaw.comVanDyke Uses Crude Phrases in Case Over Spa's Transgender Po...
Talking Points MemoTrump Judge Says Trans Rights Case Is About 'Swinging Dicks,...
The Daily Caller'Swinging Dicks': Federal Judge Lays Bare Rule Forcing Nude ...
Conservative News TodayFederal judge lights into 'WOKE' colleagues for greenlightin...
dailycallernewsfoundation.orgFederal Judge Lights Into 'Woke' Colleagues For Greenlightin...
Power LineQuote of the day
ReasonJudge VanDyke: "This is a case about swinging dicks."

A news briefing built to show both sides.

The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.

← Earlier in this briefing
Nigeria Data Protection Commission warns content creators against filming member...
Nigeria’s data protection regulator, the Nigeria Data Protection Commission (NDPC), has warned content creators against...
Technology & Society
Next in this briefing →
EU governments back proposal to ban AI systems generating sexualised deepfakes a...
EU member states on Friday backed a proposal to amend the EU’s AI Act to explicitly prohibit AI practices used to...
Technology & Society

Continue Reading

More in Rights & Justice

Explosion damages Jewish school in Amsterdam; mayor calls it a targeted attack

An overnight explosion damaged the outer wall of a Jewish school in Amsterdam’s Buitenveldert district, with...

Rights & Justice
Related this week

Canada pledges up to C$560 million to Brazilian-led tropical forest fund

Canada pledged up to C$560 million (US$392.5 million) over four years to the Brazilian-led Tropical Forests Forever...

Science & Climate
From this briefing

Allahabad High Court criticises Sambhal officials over limits on mosque worshippers, says they should resign or seek transfer if unable to maintain order

The Allahabad High Court set aside an administrative decision in Uttar Pradesh’s Sambhal district that limited the...

Rights & Justice
Back to all stories

A news briefing built to show both sides.

The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.

ReframedNews

A daily news briefing on the day’s top stories, built to show both sides.

Written by AI from news reporting. We review published briefings. Who writes this →

Navigate

Quick ReadArchiveSettings

Company

AboutHow it worksSkylark CreationsSign InTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

© 2026 Reframed.News

Made by Skylark Creations