Supreme Court declines to hear challenge to Maryland firearm-carry restrictions
The facts
- The Supreme Court declined to hear a challenge to Maryland’s firearm-carry restrictions.
- The denial leaves Maryland’s challenged firearm-carry restrictions in effect.
- Maryland restricts firearms in locations including schools, public transit, parks and places serving alcohol.
- Gun-rights advocates challenged the Maryland restrictions under the Second Amendment.
- A federal appeals court had upheld the Maryland restrictions challenged in the case.
- Justice Clarence Thomas questioned whether the restrictions fit the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation.
- Thomas said the Court should consider sensitive-place restrictions in a more narrowly focused case.
Context
What did the Supreme Court’s action do?
By declining review, the Court left in place the lower-court decision that upheld Maryland’s challenged restrictions on carrying firearms in designated public places. NBC News CBS News Maryland Matters
What locations does Maryland’s law cover?
The restrictions cover various public locations, including schools, public transit, parks, health care facilities and venues serving alcohol. NBC News CBS News JURIST
Did the Court define the limits of sensitive-place restrictions?
No. The Court did not decide the broader constitutional question, and Thomas said it could take up particular restrictions in a more narrowly focused future case. USA Today U.S. News & World R… Maryland Matters
Common ground, and where they split
- Common ground
- The Court denied review, leaving Maryland's restrictions in effect, with Thomas signaling the historical-tradition test remains unsettled and likely to resurface in a narrower case.
- Where Left and Right split
- Public spaces staying protected from guns, or a constitutional right that keeps shrinking in practice as every location becomes a sensitive place.
- Why they differ
- The divide is over values: whether the Second Amendment should be read to presumptively protect carry rights everywhere absent a matching historical ban, or to permit broad modern carve-outs for public safety.
- Watch for
- The Court is already set to hear arguments in December on whether bans on assault-style weapons are constitutional, a case that could signal how the same majority will treat gun restrictions going forward.USA Today
How left and right read it
Keeping guns out of schools, transit, parks and places serving alcohol is a basic safeguard for shared public life, so leaving the appeals court's ruling in place protects that safeguard instead of reopening it. Thomas's push to weigh these restrictions against historical tradition in a narrower case is worth watching, since the same majority has often sided with gun rights before, even though Maryland's law stands for now.
“The court's 6-3 conservative majority has frequently backed gun rights in a series of rulings that have expanded the scope of the Constitution's Second Amendment, which protects the right to bear arms.” — NBC News
An enumerated right that evaporates the moment you leave your front door is not much of a right, and the test is whether a restriction matches the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation — the question Thomas pressed here. The appeals court upheld it; the justices declined review. So when does a permit actually mean something?
“Unable to block owners from carrying concealed, the state's Legislature enacted a broader sensitive places law to put more locations out-of-bounds for those permit holders.” — Washington Times
The receipts — 28 sources
Wire services (4)
Other coverage (24)
A news briefing built to show both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.