Genetic study finds Neanderthal–human matings skewed toward Neanderthal males and human females
The facts
- Multiple genetic studies have shown that Neanderthals and anatomically modern humans interbred tens of thousands of years ago, leaving Neanderthal DNA in most present-day people of non-African ancestry.
- A new study published in the journal Science analyzed X chromosomes from ancient Neanderthal genomes and from present-day humans to investigate patterns of interbreeding.
- The study finds that gene flow between the two species was predominantly between male Neanderthals and female Homo sapiens, with relatively few pairings between male Homo sapiens and female Neanderthals.
- Researchers observed that Neanderthal X chromosomes contain a substantial excess of modern human DNA, while modern human X chromosomes show large regions—often called 'Neanderthal deserts'—where Neanderthal DNA is largely absent.
- This asymmetric pattern of DNA on the X chromosome is used by the authors to argue that social behavior and mating preferences, rather than purely biological incompatibility, played a major role in determining where Neanderthal DNA persists in the modern human genome.
- The study was led by researchers at the University of Pennsylvania, including Alexander Platt and Sarah Tishkoff.
- People today with non-African ancestry typically have about 1–4% of their genome derived from Neanderthals, averaging around 2%.
- Scientists say the reasons for the strong bias toward Neanderthal-male/Homo sapiens-female pairings, including whether encounters were consensual or involved coercion or violence, remain unknown based on current evidence.
Context
How did scientists infer that most interbreeding was between Neanderthal men and human women?
Researchers compared the X chromosomes of ancient Neanderthal genomes with those of present-day humans and found that Neanderthal X chromosomes carry an excess of modern human DNA, while modern human X chromosomes have large regions with little or no Neanderthal DNA, a pattern best explained if gene flow mainly came from Neanderthal males mating with Homo sapiens females GameReactor,Devdiscourse,NYT,Guardian,CBC News,Reuters,Nature.
What does this study suggest about earlier ideas that Neanderthal DNA was biologically incompatible with humans?
Earlier hypotheses proposed that Neanderthal DNA was largely purged from certain parts of the human genome, especially the X chromosome, because it was biologically harmful, but the new analysis shows Neanderthals themselves carried substantial modern human DNA on their X chromosomes, indicating the two groups were not strongly incompatible and that social behavior and mating patterns likely explain much of the observed distribution instead Devdiscourse,NYT,EL PAÍS,20 minutos,Reuters,Nature.
How much Neanderthal DNA do people today typically have, and who is affected?
Most people with ancestry outside sub-Saharan Africa carry a small proportion of Neanderthal DNA—commonly estimated at about 1–4% of their genome, with many reports citing around 2%—while people whose recent ancestry is entirely from sub-Saharan Africa generally have little to no Neanderthal ancestry NYT,WEB.DE,N-tv,EL MUNDO,EL PAÍS,La Nacion,India Today,20 minutos,LaVanguardia.
The receipts — 85 sources
Wire services (13)
Other coverage (72)
A news briefing built to show both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.