New York Attorney General Sues IHG and Others Over Rochester Hotel Renovation
|
The facts
- Attorney General Letitia James sued IHG, the former hotel’s owner and a renovation contractor.
- The lawsuit concerns dozens of immigrant workers recruited to renovate a former downtown Rochester Holiday Inn.
- The complaint alleges some workers were required to work up to 112 hours per week.
- The lawsuit alleges workers who sought wages were threatened with deportation.
- The complaint alleges workers and some families lived without heat, electricity or running water.
- The civil lawsuit seeks unpaid wages, restitution, damages and penalties for workers.
- IHG condemned trafficking and denied knowledge of serious misconduct alleged in the lawsuit.
Context
What does the lawsuit allege happened to the workers?
The complaint alleges that immigrant workers renovating the hotel were made to work long hours for little or no pay, were threatened with deportation when they requested wages, and were housed in unsafe conditions. NYT Investing.com Democrat and Chroni… WHEC.com
Who is named in the case?
James sued IHG Hotels & Resorts, the owner of the former Holiday Inn, and renovation contractor Roman Petrik and his company, Exterior Hotel Improvement. NYT Investing.com Times Union
What is the attorney general seeking?
The lawsuit seeks unpaid wages, restitution, damages and civil penalties for affected workers, as well as disgorgement of profits tied to their labor. Times Union Fingerlakes1.com
Common ground, and where they split
- Common ground
- Threatening deportation against workers who asked to be paid turned the employment bargain into coercion, and both sides treat the state's wage-and-penalties lawsuit as warranted.
- Where Left and Right split
- The left and the right agree the lawsuit is warranted but differ on what it proves.
- Why they differ
- The two readings diverge on trust in institutional process: one treats the alleged conduct as sufficient grounds for liability now, the other insists liability must track proof of which named party actually knew.
How left and right read it
Immigration status should never be something an employer can use to make wage theft cheap. That is exactly what's alleged here: workers put on shifts of up to 112 hours a week, living without heat, electricity or running water, and told they could be deported if they asked to be paid. The state is right to demand unpaid wages, restitution, damages and penalties. Who else was protected by their silence?
“Dozens of immigrants were exploited while renovating a Rochester, N.Y., hotel and threatened with deportation if they complained, according to a lawsuit filed on Thursday by the New York attorney general.” — The New York Times
Work performed is a debt owed, and a worker who asks to be paid is enforcing a bargain, not begging a favor. Deportation threats against workers seeking wages turn that bargain into coercion, so the demand for unpaid wages, restitution, damages and penalties is exactly what courts exist for. But proof must come first. IHG denied knowledge of the alleged misconduct, and liability should follow who actually knew.
Deportation threats turned pay requests into coercion. What remains to prove is who knew enough to be responsible.
The receipts — 11 sources
Wire services (3)
Other coverage (8)
A news briefing built to show both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.