German court rejects climate lawsuits against BMW and Mercedes-Benz
The facts
- Germany's Federal Court of Justice ruled on climate lawsuits filed by Deutsche Umwelthilfe against BMW and Mercedes-Benz.
- The lawsuits sought to stop BMW and Mercedes-Benz from selling new cars with combustion engines after November 2030.
- The court rejected the lawsuits and returned the matter to the lower-court outcome, with the DUH's appeals dismissed.
- The case had already failed in earlier proceedings in Munich and Stuttgart before reaching the Federal Court of Justice.
- DUH argued that the automakers' emissions would use too much of the global and national CO2 budget and could force more restrictive climate measures later.
- The legal argument relied in part on Germany's Constitutional Court's 2021 climate ruling, which said the state had a duty to protect future generations from climate change.
- The central legal question was whether companies can be required by civil courts to take climate measures even without a specific state rule ordering them to do so.
Context
What did Deutsche Umwelthilfe want the court to order?
DUH wanted BMW and Mercedes-Benz barred from selling new combustion-engine cars after November 2030 T-online.de,tagesschau.de,Frankfurter Allgeme….
Why did DUH say the automakers should be restricted?
The group argued that continued sales of combustion-engine cars would consume too much of the CO2 budget and make later climate action more severe, limiting freedom in the future N-tv,DIE WELT,Deutschlandfunk.
Why was this case considered significant?
It tested whether civil courts can impose climate-related obligations on private companies, not just on governments through legislation Der Tagesspiegel,taz.de,Deutschlandfunk.
The receipts — 59 sources
Other coverage (59)
A news briefing built to show both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.