Iran's Chief Negotiator Accuses Trump of 'Theater Diplomacy' as Hormuz Shipping Deal Talks Continue
The Facts
- Mohammad Bagher Ghalibaf, Iran's parliament speaker and chief negotiator, wrote on X on Thursday that Trump's alternating threats and offers amounted to "theater diplomacy on loop."
- Trump said he called off a planned large-scale strike on Iran because he saw progress toward a deal; Iranian officials denied that negotiations with Washington were underway or imminent.
- Iran and Oman have been negotiating an arrangement under which ships entering the Persian Gulf would travel a route near Iran's coast and ships leaving would travel a route near Oman, with a "service fee" covering security, environmental and personnel costs and revenue split evenly between the two countries.
- Iran's semi-official Fars news agency reported that text under review in Iran's parliament would bar U.S. and Israeli vessels from the strait, require compensation from countries Tehran deems hostile, ban Israel-related cargo, and set fees covering insurance and environmental costs.
- Reuters reported, citing an Iranian source and regional officials, that the Iran-Oman arrangement would give Tehran control over vessels entering the Persian Gulf, which the agency described as one of the largest concessions to Iran to date, with significant details still unresolved.
- A U.S. official familiar with the talks said the Iranian account of the terms was not accurate, and Pentagon officials were reported to be skeptical of the emerging arrangement.
- Oil prices rose after Fars reported explosions near Qeshm Island and said Iran had attacked "hostile targets" in the Strait of Hormuz, with Brent crude climbing above $83 a barrel and West Texas Intermediate trading near $78.
- Energy flows through the strait have been constricted since the U.S. and Israel attacked Iran in February, and shipping traffic through Hormuz has been near a standstill.
- Trump said publicly that the Iran-Oman negotiations were "moving along" and that the strait was partly open, even as Iranian lawmakers pushed to exclude American ships.
Context
Why does the Strait of Hormuz matter?
It is one of the world's most important energy shipping routes, and disruptions there move global oil prices; reports of Iranian strikes in the strait pushed Brent above $83 a barrel and WTI near $78 NDTV Profit,cnbctv18.com. Energy flows have been throttled since the U.S. and Israel attacked Iran in February, making a reopening arrangement central to expectations for restored shipping Colorado Springs Ga…,Business Standard.
What exactly is in dispute between Washington and Tehran?
The two sides give conflicting accounts of whether bilateral talks are happening at all: Trump said the outlines of a deal had been settled, while Iranian officials said no dialogue was open and that decisions on Washington would depend on future events CNBC,3Cat. Separately, a U.S. official said Iran's public description of the Hormuz terms was inaccurate, and any arrangement was framed by Washington as temporary Lenta.ru,Коммерсант.….
What remains unresolved in the Iran-Oman arrangement?
Sources told Reuters that important questions remain, including how "control" over vessels would be defined and whether fees on passing ships would be mandatory or voluntary, with Gulf states pressing for voluntary payments kp.ru,Коммерсант.…,"Insan Haqları Uğru…. Reports have described a deal of about 60 days in duration, and the text is under review by Iran's parliament kp.ru,Аргументы и…,Colorado Springs Ga….
Where Left and Right agree, and where they split
- Where Left and Right agree
- Neither read takes Washington's account at face value: the strait is near a standstill with Brent above $83, and the terms on the table remain disputed and unsettled.
- Where Left and Right split
- The left and the right split on whether this is theater covering the costs of force, or a deal handing Iran the strait.
How left and right read it
Iran's parliament speaker wrote on X Thursday that Trump's alternating threats and offers amounted to "theater diplomacy on loop," after Trump said he called off a large-scale strike because he saw progress toward a deal — progress Iranian officials denied was happening at all. Meanwhile the strait has been near a standstill since the U.S. and Israeli attacks in February, with Brent above $83. Announcements are not negotiations. The bill for force lands on people who never got a vote on it.
A "service fee" split evenly between Tehran and Muscat, inbound traffic hugging Iran's coast, outbound hugging Oman's — that is a tollbooth on a waterway that has always been open to all. Reuters calls it one of the largest concessions to Iran yet; a U.S. official disputes Tehran's account and the Pentagon is skeptical. Text under review would bar American and Israeli vessels outright. Since when does the United States pay for passage it once guaranteed?
This isn't really a story about a shipping fee — it's about whether the scandal is who pays for force or who ends up controlling the water.
The receipts — all 82 sources
Independent coverage (50)
Facts first. Then every angle.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief — the facts everyone agrees on, then the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.