Skip to content
ReframedNewsLeft · Right · Centered
Quick ReadArchiveAboutSign in
Briefing stories›Rights & Justice

Maduro and Wife Ask US Judge to Dismiss Drug-Trafficking Indictment, Citing Head-of-State Immunity

Story date · Thursday, September 3, 2026The United StatesRights & JusticeWell-covered

The facts

  • Nicolás Maduro and Cilia Flores asked a Manhattan federal judge on Wednesday to dismiss the drug-trafficking indictment against them.
  • Their filing argues the court lacks jurisdiction because Venezuela recognizes Maduro as its head of state.
  • Defense lawyer Barry Pollack filed an alternative motion seeking dismissal of only the narcoterrorism conspiracy count.
  • Maduro and Flores have pleaded not guilty to the federal drug and firearms charges.
  • US forces seized the couple in Caracas on January 3 and brought them to New York.
  • The pair have been held in a Brooklyn federal jail since their capture.
  • Their trial is scheduled to begin June 1, 2027 if the dismissal bid fails.
  • President Donald Trump said the couple could face an additional charge over allegedly sending prisoners from Venezuelan jails to the United States.

Context

What is the immunity argument, and why do observers doubt it will succeed?

The defense invokes the long-standing principle of international law that sitting heads of state are immune from criminal prosecution abroad, and argues Maduro's alleged conduct fell within his official duties Коммерсант.…,IndexHR,Jutarnji list. Analysts note US courts have been reluctant to apply international law in criminal cases, and that Washington has not recognized Maduro as Venezuela's legitimate president since 2019, which weakens the claim under US precedent Terra,Net.hr. Coverage has drawn comparisons to the earlier US prosecution of Panama's Manuel Noriega El Tiempo.

What are the charges and what happens next in the case?

Maduro, 63, faces four counts including narcoterrorism conspiracy, cocaine importation and possession of automatic weapons SAPO,Estadão,O TEMPO. Prosecutors have until October 2 to respond to the dismissal motions CNN Español,BioBioChile. Reports differ on the hearing date: CNN Español says the judge set oral argument for November 17 CNN Español, while Dawn reports a hearing on the dismissal arguments scheduled for November 7 Dawn.

Who is governing Venezuela while Maduro is detained?

Maduro's former vice president, Delcy Rodríguez, has governed Venezuela on an interim basis since the January 3 operation, under pressure from Washington El Tiempo,Estadão.

How left and right read it

Left says

No court should be asked to launder a military seizure into a lawful prosecution. Yet the only reason this indictment sits in Manhattan is that US forces took Maduro and Flores out of Caracas on January 3 and brought them to a Brooklyn jail — and Trump is already floating an additional charge on top. That precedent is the danger. Dismiss it, and send them back.

Right says

American forces exist to defend this country, not to deliver foreign heads of state to a Brooklyn jail. The indictment's own theory is that Maduro used his office to conspire with cartels, which makes this a question of statecraft rather than ordinary crime — yet it was settled by force in Caracas on January 3, and the president is already floating another count on top. Drop the case.

“Maduro used his position -- first as a deputy in Venezuela's National Assembly and then as the country's president -- to conspire with narco-terrorists from some of the world's largest cartels to import cocaine into the United States.” — Fox News↗

See this differently than someone you know would?

The receipts — 100 sources

Wire services (2)

APJamaica GleanerEx-Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro and wife seek to end ...
AFPJamaica ObserverVenezuela's Maduro seek immunity from US drug charges

Other coverage (98)

Entorno InteligenteInmunidad soberana: La carta legal con la que Maduro busca f...
TVC News NigeriaVenezuela's Maduro Seeks Immunity From US Drug Charges
The NationMaduro's defense team asks US judge to dismiss charges, citi...
LA TERCERADefensa de Maduro busca que se desestimen los cargos en su c...
DawnMaduro seeks immunity from US drug charges
Anadolu AjansıMaduro's defense team asks US judge to dismiss charges, citi...
LARED21Defensa de Nicolás Maduro pide a juez de Nueva York desestim...
Jammu Kashmir Latest News | Tourism | Breaking News J&KEx-Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro, wife seek to end dru...
América TelevisiónNicolás Maduro pide anular su juicio en EE.UU.
Canal NNicolás Maduro pide a justicia de EE.UU. anular proceso pena...
Tengrinews.kzНиколас Мадуро и его жена попросили снять с них обвинения
Diario Río NegroNicolás Maduro apela a su inmunidad y pide desestimar los ca...
BioBioChileNicolás Maduro intenta anular los cargos en su contra en EEU...
Los AndesLa defensa de Nicolás Maduro pidió desestimar el caso en Est...
Radio Mitre ✋🏽🧼🤚🏽Nicolás Maduro pide desestimar su caso en Estados Unidos y a...
Las2orillasCon el refuerzo de dos abogados gringos de peso Nicolás Madu...
HotAirMaduro to Federal Court: I Have Sovereign Immunity, You Know
VEJAMaduro invoca imunidade de chefe de Estado para pedir retira...
www.vanguardia.comDefensa de Nicolás Maduro pidió en EE. UU. desestimar el cas...
HoraceroDefensa de Nicolás Maduro pide su libertad
RT en EspañolLa defensa de Maduro apela a este argumento para solicitar l...
TC TelevisiónMaduro pide a un tribunal de Nueva York desestimar su caso a...
T13 (teletrece)Maduro apela a su inmunidad y pide desestimar cargos en su c...
Diario PanoramaMaduro busca frenar el juicio en Estados Unidos y sus abogad...
LaPatilla.com¿Puede Maduro alegar inmunidad? Su defensa abre una batalla ...
Alto NivelMaduro pide a Estados Unidos desestimar su caso por inmunida...
El Heraldo de M�xicoNicolás Maduro y Cilia Flores buscan desestimar cargos en Es...
Teletica (Canal 7)Nicolás Maduro apela a su inmunidad y pide desestimar cargos...
One America News NetworkMaduro and his wife ask judge to throw out federal drug-traf...
TeleamazonasMaduro apela a su inmunidad y pide desestimar cargos en su c...
Washington Times5 questions about the Maduro immunity challenge
El Tiempo¿Tiene Nicolás Maduro inmunidad presidencial ante la justici...
CNN Español¿En qué se basa la defensa de Nicolás Maduro para solicitar ...
www.expreso.ecNicolás Maduro pide desestimar su caso en EE.UU. argumentand...
Diario de Los AndesMaduro pidió desestimar su caso en EE UU argumentando inmuni...
JURISTFormer Venezuelan President Maduro and wife move to dismiss ...
noi.mdНиколасу Мадуро могут быть предъявлены новые обвинения
DominicanToday.comNicolas Maduro claims presidential immunity and asks New Yor...
International Business TimesMaduro Says U.S. Violated Venezuelan Sovereignty When He Was...
O GloboMaduro invoca imunidade de chefe de Estado e pede à Justiça ...
HomeMaduro apela à sua imunidade e pede retirada das acusações n...
O TEMPOMaduro invoca imunidade e pede retirada das acusações nos Es...
Free Malaysia TodayVenezuela's Maduro seek immunity from US drug charges
Albeu.com - Lajmet e fundit dhe jo vetëm!Maduro defies U.S. authorities: Seeks dismissal of case by i...
The New Indian ExpressAbducted Venezuelan leader Maduro seeks immunity from US dru...
Miami HeraldMaduro asks U.S. judge to dismiss drug case, claiming immuni...
EstadãoMaduro pede à Justiça dos EUA retirada das acusações de tráf...
Jovem Pan – Esportes, entretenimento, notícias e vídeos com credibilidadeMaduro pede que Justiça dos EUA rejeite acusações de tráfico...
YahooMaduro claims immunity, asks judge to dismiss drug-trafficki...
Novi listMaduro se poziva na imunitet i traži od američkog suca odbac...
GZHMaduro apela à sua imunidade e pede retirada das acusações n...
LifeZetteNicolás Maduro and Wife Claim Immunity in Brazen Bid to Bury...
UOL notíciasMaduro apela à sua imunidade e pede retirada das acusações n...
kp.ruАдвокаты Мадуро требуют прекратить дело против него в США: н...
Money TimesMaduro alega imunidade e pede que juiz dos EUA rejeite acusa...
Daily SabahMaduro, wife want US drug charges dismissed on immunity grou...
Парламентская ГазетаReuters: Мадуро призвал американский суд снять с него обвине...
DT NewsSon explains how Maduro jail pics got on social media
West Hawaii TodayVenezuela's Maduro asserts immunity, urges US judge to dismi...
Anadolu AjansıДельси Родригес: выборы в Венесуэле пройдут, когда будут соз...
AolMaduro, wife seek dismissal of drug trafficking indictment o...
ExameMaduro alega imunidade de chefe de Estado nos EUA: entenda o...
Коммерсант.ruНиколас Мадуро призвал американский суд снять с него все обв...
Brasil 247Defesa de Maduro pede arquivamento de processo nos EUA
NEWS.amТрамп допустил, что Мадуро предъявят новые обвинения в США
RT на русскомТрамп допустил предъявление Мадуро новых обвинений в США
rossaprimavera.ruМадуро попросил закрыть возбужденное против него уголовое де...
armenpress.amМадуро и его супруга обратились к судье США с просьбой прекр...
Lenta.ruМадуро попросил закрыть возбужденное против него уголовое де...
Ақ Жайық"Я военнопленный, меня похитили": Николас Мадуро и его жена ...
SAPOMaduro invoca imunidade soberana para pedir arquivamento de ...
euronewsЭкс-президент Венесуэлы Николас Мадуро и жена добиваются сня...
euronewsVenezuela: Maduro e mulher tentam travar acusações de tráfic...
tportal.hrSvrgnuti Maduro želi se riješiti optužbi, javio se i njegov ...
Telegram.hrMaduro se poziva na imunitet i traži od američkog suca odbac...
Dnevnik.hrMaduro od suda u New Yorku traži odbacivanje optužnice
Net.hrMaduro se poziva na imunitet, traje velika borba za slobodu:...
Jutarnji listMaduro traži da se odbace optužbe protiv njega za kazneno dj...
IndexHRMaduro od suda u New Yorku traži odbacivanje optužnice
Interfax.ruЧета Мадуро добивается прекращения уголовного преследования ...
vesti.ruЮристы Мадуро заявили суду США о неприкосновенности президен...
Аргументы и фактыТрамп не исключил, что Мадуро могут предъявить новые обвинен...
NEWSru.co.ilМадуро потребовал прекратить уголовное дело в США, сославшис...
Телеканал «Звезда»Адвокаты Мадуро потребовали прекратить дело против него
РамблерТрамп допустил новые обвинения против Мадуро
Московский КомсомолецТрамп допустил новые обвинения против Мадуро
ВзглядЗащита Мадуро потребовала закрыть дело в США против президен...
Report İnformasiya AgentliyiТрамп: Мадуро могут предъявить новые обвинения
Brasil 247Maduro alega imunidade e pede que juiz dos EUA rejeite acusa...
РамблерЗащита Мадуро потребовала прекратить дело в США
РИА НовостиТрамп допустил, что Мадуро могут предъявить новое обвинение
РИА НовостиЗащита Мадуро просит прекратить дело в США
TerraMaduro alega imunidade e pede que juiz dos EUA rejeite acusa...
UOL notíciasMaduro alega imunidade e pede que juiz dos EUA rejeite acusa...
Fox NewsMaduro claims immunity, asks judge to dismiss drug-trafficki...
MignewsМадуро потребовал снять с него обвинения в США - MigNews - Н...
Correio do povoMaduro apela à imunidade e pede retirada de acusações nos EU...
Diario de PernambucoMaduro apela à sua imunidade e pede retirada das acusações n...

A news briefing built to show both sides.

The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.

← Earlier in this briefing
Israel Frees Five Lebanese Detainees Amid U.S.-Brokered Talks With Beirut
Israel began handing over five Lebanese civilians on Thursday, the first such releases since the latest...
International Affairs
Next in this briefing →
France reports hottest summer on record in 2026, with 53 days of heatwave condit...
French Environment Minister Monique Barbut announced on Thursday that France had lived through its hottest summer since...
Science & Climate

Continue Reading

More in Rights & Justice

Treasury and IRS Propose Rule Ending Tax-Exempt Status for Private Schools That Consider Race

The Treasury Department and the IRS on Thursday proposed regulations that would deny federal tax-exempt status to...

Rights & Justice
Related this week

U.S. attorney tells Elizabeth Warren to preserve records on potential Trump-related investigations

U.S. Attorney Aaron Reitz of the Southern District of Texas sent Sen. Elizabeth Warren a letter demanding preservation...

U.S. Politics
From this briefing

Vance Declines to Call the US-Iran Conflict a 'War' and Gives No End Date

Vice President JD Vance told reporters at a White House briefing on Thursday that he would not describe the fighting...

U.S. Politics
Back to all stories

A news briefing built to show both sides.

The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.

ReframedNews

A daily news briefing on the day’s top stories, built to show both sides.

Written by AI from news reporting. We review published briefings. Who writes this →

Navigate

Quick ReadArchiveSettings

Company

AboutHow it worksSkylark CreationsSign InTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

© 2026 Reframed.News

Made by Skylark Creations