Supreme Court ruling on FTC firing expands Trump’s authority over independent agencies
The Facts
- The Supreme Court ruled 6-3 that Trump had the authority to fire FTC Commissioner Rebecca Slaughter.
- The ruling overturned or set aside the 1935 Humphrey’s Executor precedent that had limited a president’s ability to remove leaders of independent agencies.
- The decision broadens presidential power over independent regulatory agencies beyond the FTC and is expected to affect other agencies across the federal government.
- Before this ruling, Trump had already removed or pressured out officials at multiple independent agencies, and the New York Times reported that at least 13 agencies had been affected in ways that ended Democratic majorities at most of them.
- The court treated the Federal Reserve differently for now, preventing the immediate removal of Fed Governor Lisa D. Cook while her case continues.
- The ruling is likely to shape or weaken pending legal challenges brought by officials Trump fired from other agencies, including cases involving members of the Consumer Product Safety Commission.
How left and right are reading this
- Both agree
- The ruling reaches beyond one FTC seat, reshaping independent agencies across government and likely affecting other officials’ legal challenges as presidential removal power expands.
- They split on
- Whether the story is about weakening independent agencies as a check on presidential power, or restoring presidential control over officials exercising executive authority.
Analytical frames for this storyTap to explore
Context
What case was the Supreme Court deciding?
The case centered on Trump’s firing of FTC Commissioner Rebecca Slaughter, a Democratic member of the commission, after the White House said her continued service was inconsistent with the administration’s priorities Guardian,NY Post,CNBC.
Why does this matter beyond the FTC?
Independent agencies such as the FTC were created with leadership protections intended to limit direct presidential control, and the court’s ruling means presidents can now remove many agency leaders more freely, affecting how those bodies operate across the federal government NYT,Aol,India Today.
What remains unresolved after the ruling?
One major unresolved issue is how far the decision extends in practice, especially for agencies with different structures; the court indicated that the Federal Reserve may be treated differently and left Lisa D. Cook in place for now while her challenge proceeds NYT,Investing.com,Independent.
Facts first. Then every angle.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief — the facts everyone agrees on, then the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.
View all 100 sources
Wire services (6)
Independent coverage (50)
The GuardianThe supreme court has again undermined the power of Congress...
The New York TimesOpinion | Congress Cleaned Up After Nixon. After Trump, It'l...
eNCAnewsSupreme Court boosts Trump's power to fire officials, but pr...
WIONUS Supreme Court hands Trump 'greatest increase in president...
CNN InternationalAnalysis: How the Supreme Court became a power that is resha...
FirstpostDid US Supreme Court just make Trump the most powerful presi...
Power LineThe Supreme Court Implements Article II
New York PostSupreme Court ruling gives Trump a chance to finally slay th...
CNN InternationalJohn Roberts fought for decades to get rid of the 1935 prece...
TheBlaze'BIG WIN': Trump calls SCOTUS 'Slaughter' ruling the greates...
Alternet.orgThe Supreme Court just changed everything about American dem...
The Boston GlobeSupreme Court expands Trump's power to fire officials, but b...
ReasonCan Trump v. Slaughter be Used to Challenge the Continued Le...
The Wall Street JournalOpinion | A Supreme Court Split Decision on Executive Power
Raw StoryCongress' power was just 'nuked from orbit' as the system ri...
Raw StorySupreme Court just swung a 'wrecking ball' at the federal go...
The Hill5 takeaways on divided day for Trump at Supreme Court
HuffPostThe Supreme Court's Seemingly Contradictory Trump Rulings Hi...
PC MagazineSupreme Court Gives Trump the Green Light to Fire Heads of F...
Slate MagazineThe Supreme Court Just Handed Trump the Keys to the Entire K...
Raw StoryExpert slams GOP pundit's analogy for controversial Supreme ...
The Express TribuneSC backs Trump's FTC firing, expands presidential power
NBC NewsTrump's voting restrictions face roadblocks from Congress an...
The Philadelphia InquirerSupreme Court expands Trump's power over the federal bureauc...
The New RepublicThe Supreme Court Gave Trump Almost Everything He Wanted
BBCOne big win and three defeats for Trump in dramatic day at S...
NewsMaxFormer FTC Official Asks Congress to Check Trump
Bloomberg BusinessSupreme Court Expands Trump's Power to Fire Federal Bureaucr...
Los Angeles TimesContributor: The Supreme Court just handed the president eve...
The New York TimesVideo: Supreme Court Expands Presidential Powers to Fire Ind...
EsquireThe President Is Dangerously Close to Gaining an Executive P...
The Boston GlobeSupreme Court is turning Trump into the king he wants to be
www.theepochtimes.comKey Takeaways From Supreme Court's Rulings on Trump's Firing...
India TodayUS Supreme Court vastly expands Trump's presidential powers ...
Slate MagazineThe Supreme Court Takes One More Big Step Toward Autocracy
The HillEx-FTC commissioner calls on Congress to reassert authority ...
New York PostSupreme Court allows Trump to say 'you're fired' to meddling...
CNNTakeaways from the Supreme Court's decisions expanding Trump...
Channel 3000Takeaways from the Supreme Court's decisions expanding Trump...
Firstpost'Big win': Trump hails Supreme Court ruling expanding presid...
VoxThe Supreme Court just made Trump the most powerful presiden...
TimesNowSupreme Court Hands Trump Major Victory, Upholds Firing of F...
Raw StoryTrump's monumental Supreme Court win shocks experts
CBS NewsSupreme Court expands presidential firing power, overturning...
The New York TimesFired F.T.C. Commissioner Warns of Potential for Presidentia...
The Financial ExpressSCOTUS expands Trump powers over independent govt agencies w...
Bloomberg BusinessThe Supreme Court Drew the Right Line on Trump's Firing Spre...
Los Angeles TimesSupreme Court: Trump may fire heads of independent agencies,...
The GuardianOutcry over supreme court decision to grant Trump power to f...
The New York TimesOpinion | The Court Just Handed Trump a Dangerous New Power
About these frames
The Watchdog: Wrongdoing, responsibility, corruption, transparency. Who knew what, when, and what they did about it.
The Advocate: Liberty, speech, privacy, autonomy, rights, consent, choice. What freedoms are at stake.
The Architect: Stability, law, enforcement, institutional design, separation of powers, regulatory process, rule of law. How are order and governance maintained?
See this differently than someone you know would? Two ways to keep it going.
The dial works on any URL — paste an article you read elsewhere this week.