US envoys say Russia may accept Article 5-style security guarantees for Ukraine
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
The facts
- Jared Kushner said Russia was open to Ukraine receiving security guarantees modeled on NATO’s Article 5.
- NATO’s Article 5 treats an armed attack on one member as an attack on all members.
- The proposed guarantee’s form and acceptance by Russia and Ukraine remain unresolved.
- Zelenskyy asked the United States to clarify what an Article 5-like guarantee would mean for Ukraine.
- Kushner and Steve Witkoff met Zelenskyy and representatives of the Coalition of the Willing in Berlin.
- Trump said he would not discuss US security guarantees until a peace agreement is reached.
Context
What is an Article 5-style security guarantee?
It would be modeled on NATO’s collective-defense principle, under which an armed attack on one ally is treated as an attack on all. Ukraine is not being described as receiving NATO membership in these accounts. NY Post NY Post Euronews English
What has Russia said about the proposed guarantee?
Kushner said Russian officials had become comfortable with the concept. The reported position is not a final agreement, and the specific terms have not been publicly defined. Hill CNBC Euronews English
Why are the talks focused on security guarantees?
Zelenskyy said Ukraine needs clarity on how the United States and Europe would respond to any future Russian attack, underscoring that the guarantee is intended for a postwar scenario. Euronews English
Common ground, and where they split
- Common ground
- The security guarantee's form remains undefined, and both frames treat that ambiguity as a problem that must be resolved before Ukraine is bound to anything.
- Where Left and Right split
- The left and the right split on whether Ukraine needs clarity now or the US needs leverage later.
- Why they differ
- The divide is one of trust in institutions: the left doubts an undefined pledge can bind Washington or Moscow, while the right treats ambiguity as leverage reserved for a final bargain, not evidence either side is negotiating in bad faith.
How left and right read it
A vague guarantee guarantees nothing. Article 5 means an attack on one is an attack on all, yet this promise's form and acceptance remain unresolved — that is why Zelenskyy asked Washington to clarify what it would mean for Ukraine, while Trump withholds any guarantee talk until a peace deal is reached. Kyiv should not be asked to accept, behind closed doors, what no one has defined.
“Donald Trump's top foreign envoys have suggested that Ukraine could still join the Nato military alliance in closed-door talks over the past few months, according to a shocking new report.” — The Independent
A guarantee given before the war ends is given away for free. So Trump is right to hold American commitments back until a peace agreement is reached: Kushner reports Russia open to an Article 5-style pledge — an attack on one treated as an attack on all — yet its form remains unresolved, so the terms, lines included, belong in the final bargain. Settle it all, then sign.
“Giving Ukraine that privilege, however, is almost certain to require Kyiv to agree to freeze the current battle lines.” — New York Post
The guarantee's terms stay undefined. The fight is whether Ukraine needs them spelled out now or settled only when the final deal is signed.
The receipts — 99 sources
Wire services (3)
Other coverage (96)
A news briefing built to show both sides.
The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.