Skip to content
ReframedNewsLeft · Right · Centered
Quick ReadArchiveAboutSign in
Briefing stories›Technology & Society

Justice Department Files Brief Backing OpenAI in New York Times Copyright Case

Story date · Wednesday, September 2, 2026The United StatesTechnology & SocietyWell-covered
  
 
 
 
 
           
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
COPYRIGHT, MACHINES AND THE PUBLIC INTERESTREFRAMED ILLUSTRATION

The facts

  • The Justice Department filed a statement of interest in Manhattan federal court supporting OpenAI and Microsoft in The New York Times copyright suit.
  • The filing argues that training large language models on copyrighted texts is protected by the fair use doctrine.
  • The New York Times sued OpenAI and Microsoft in 2023, alleging they used millions of its articles without permission.
  • Government lawyers argued that a robust domestic AI industry is a national security interest.
  • The United States is not a party to the case, and the filing carries advisory rather than binding legal weight.
  • The filing appears to be the first time the U.S. government has taken a position in the AI training copyright cases.
  • The consolidated litigation includes roughly a dozen other plaintiffs, among them Ziff Davis, book authors and The Intercept.
  • The statement of interest runs 20 pages.

Context

What is a statement of interest, and does it decide the case?

Court rules allow the Justice Department to file a statement of interest in pending litigation even when the government is not a party Washington Post. Such a filing has advisory rather than legal weight, but could bolster tech companies defending against copyright claims Aol,Guardian.

What is 'fair use' and how does it apply here?

Fair use is an exception in U.S. copyright law permitting unauthorized use of protected works in certain circumstances, such as when the use is considered transformative uol.com.br. The core dispute is whether training models like ChatGPT on news articles qualifies Yahoo! Finance,WSJ.

What did the government say the consequences of a publisher win would be?

The Justice Department wrote that "the creative possibilities and public benefits" of training on such content "far outweigh any competitive harm" Yahoo! Finance. It said a ruling for publishers could hinder AI development, limit competition among AI firms and hurt U.S. competitiveness with foreign developers CNET, and argued large publishers would disproportionately benefit from licensing requirements Nieman Lab.

Common ground, and where they split

Common ground
Both treat copyright doctrine, not national security, as what actually decides this: the twenty pages bind no one, and invoking a strategic interest settles nothing legally.
Where Left and Right split
Writers being asked to underwrite an industry without payment, or courts applying fair use as written rather than inventing a licensing regime.
Why they differ
The divide is about values, not facts: one side treats fair use as a settled legal rule that copyright already answers, the other treats payment to creators as the prior question no statute settles.

How left and right read it

Left says

The people who actually write the words are the ones being asked to subsidize this industry, and the government just put its thumb on that scale. Twenty pages arguing that training on copyrighted text is fair use, filed on behalf of no party to the case, against reporters, book authors and outlets like The Intercept who allege millions of articles were taken without permission. Calling that a national security interest doesn't answer the question of who gets paid. Compensate the creators first.

“In its filing, the Justice Department said that constraining the development of large language models like ChatGPT would hinder important creative and scientific progress.” — Washington Post↗

Right says

American AI gets built here only if courts apply copyright law as written, rather than inventing a mandatory licensing regime around it. That is why the Justice Department's twenty pages matter: not a party to the case, it argued that training on copyrighted text falls within fair use and that a strong domestic AI industry is a national security interest. The filing binds no one. Fair use already answers this.

“The Justice Department is backing OpenAI in its high-stakes legal battle with the New York Times, arguing in a court filing that using copyrighted content to train artificial intelligence models does not violate the law.” — New York Post↗

See this differently than someone you know would?

The receipts — 92 sources

Wire services (15)

APgorgenewscenter.comTrump administration backs OpenAI in New York Times' copyrig...
APWTOPJury in Lindsay Clancy trial tells judge for a second time t...
APThe Boston GlobeTrump administration backs OpenAI in New York Times' copyrig...
APMail OnlineTrump administration backs OpenAI in New York Times' copyrig...
APYahoo! FinanceTrump administration backs OpenAI in New York Times' copyrig...
APYakima Herald-RepublicTrump administration backs OpenAI in New York Times' copyrig...
APOwensboro Messenger-InquirerTrump administration backs OpenAI in New York Times' copyrig...
ReutersMyrtleBeachOnlineUS government backs OpenAI in New York Times copyright case
ReutersAolUS government backs OpenAI in New York Times copyright case ...
ReutersIdaho StatesmanUS government backs OpenAI in New York Times copyright case
ReutersInvesting.comUS government backs OpenAI in New York Times copyright case ...
ReutersMyrtleBeachOnlineUS government backs OpenAI in New York Times copyright case
APU.S. News & World ReportTrump Administration Backs OpenAI in New York Times' Copyrig...
ReutersReutersUS government backs OpenAI in New York Times copyright case
ReutersU.S. News & World ReportUS Government Backs OpenAI in New York Times Copyright Case

Other coverage (77)

Génération-NTL'administration Trump soutient OpenAI face au New York Time...
Free Malaysia TodayUS govt sides with OpenAI in New York Times copyright lawsui...
ETV Bharat NewsTrump Administration Backs OpenAI In New York Times' Copyrig...
Poder360Trump apoia OpenAI em processo contra o "New York Times
The Logical IndianUS Government Backs OpenAI in Copyright Fight: What It Means...
Punch NewspapersUS sides with OpenAI in New York Times copyright lawsuit
Les SmartgridsIA : le fair use redéfinit l'entraînement des modèles
Economie MatinIA et droits d'auteur : qui paiera vraiment la facture de l'...
Northwest Arkansas Democrat GazetteDOJ urges judge to rule for OpenAI, Microsoft in suit | Nort...
O CafezinhoGoverno Trump apoia OpenAI em ação de direitos autorais
nextinpactLe gouvernement américain vole au secours d'OpenAI dans son ...
RapplerUS government backs OpenAI in New York Times copyright case
TimesNowUS Defends OpenAI In New York Times Copyright Case, Says AI ...
NewsBytesTrump supports OpenAI in copyright fight with New York Times
The Mac ObserverTrump Administration Sides With OpenAI In New York Times Law...
Baller AlertSony And Warner Accuse Claude AI Of Ripping Off Hit Songs
Economic TimesOpenAI copyright case: US government backs OpenAI in New Yor...
Le Monde.frIA : l'administration Trump défend le droit d'OpenAI à utili...
Startup FortuneThe Justice Department Sided With OpenAI Against The New Yor...
The HinduTrump administration backs OpenAI in New York Times' copyrig...
Diário do Centro do MundoPor que o governo Trump decidiu apoiar a OpenAI contra o New...
Digital Music NewsDOJ Says Training AI on IP 'Is Exceedingly Transformative'
CryptopolitanUS backs OpenAI fair-use claim, warns of AI licensing oligop...
Daily NewsTrump Justice Department weighs in on OpenAI copyright case,...
The Next WebJustice Department sides with OpenAI in publishers' copyrigh...
TRT WorldOpenAI gets Trump backing in blockbuster battle over AI and ...
Daily NewsTrump Justice Department weighs in on OpenAI copyright case,...
AppleInsiderAppleInsider.com
Music Business WorldwideDonald Trump's administration just sided with OpenAI in a ke...
Australian Financial ReviewTrump administration backs OpenAI in media copyright battle
Yahoo! FinanceTrump Administration Sides With OpenAI Over The New York Tim...
GizmodoTrump Admin Teams Up With OpenAI in Its Fight Against the Ne...
Florida Politics - Campaigns & Elections. Lobbying & Government.Donald Trump admin backs OpenAI in New York Times' copyright...
The GuardianTrump administration sides with OpenAI in lawsuit against Ne...
Asianet News Network Pvt LtdOpenAI Gets Trump Administration's Backing In NYT Copyright ...
RocketNews | Top News Stories From Around the GlobeThe Trump administration is supporting OpenAI in the NYT cop...
New York PostDOJ sides with OpenAI over NY Times in lawsuit alleging AI c...
Yahoo! FinanceTrump backs OpenAI in copyright battle with New York Times
The TelegraphTrump backs OpenAI in copyright battle with New York Times
Nieman LabTrump administration says a New York Times win in OpenAI law...
GV WireJustice Dept. Sides With OpenAI in New York Times Copyright ...
NourishTrump administration backs OpenAI in New York Times' copyrig...
news.bloomberglaw.comTrump Administration Backs OpenAI in NY Times Copyright Suit
Folha de S.PauloGoverno Trump apoia OpenAI em disputa com New York Times - 0...
WccftechTrump Administration Backs OpenAI In Its Fight With The New ...
Crypto BriefingUS Department of Justice backs OpenAI, argues restricting AI...
MediaPostTrump Admin To Judge: AI Training Is 'Fair Use'
The Wall Street JournalU.S. Government Backs OpenAI in Copyright Fight With Publish...
MacGenerationLe gouvernement américain vole au secours d'OpenAI dans son ...
Yahoo! FinanceTrump administration backs OpenAI in New York Times copyrigh...
WiredTrump Administration Sides With OpenAI in New York Times Cop...
The InterceptTrump Admin Tells Court: Let OpenAI Rip Off The Intercept's ...
CNETTrump Administration Sides With OpenAI in Publishers' Copyri...
The Straits TimesUS government backs OpenAI in New York Times copyright case
Olhar Digital - O futuro passa primeiro aquiTrump entra na briga da OpenAI contra o New York Times por d...
MandatoryDonald Trump Administration Sides With OpenAI Against Media ...
uol.com.brGoverno dos EUA defende OpenAI em ação do NYT sobre direitos...
BillboardAs Music Industry Battles AI Firms Over Training, Trump Admi...
The Hollywood ReporterTrump's DoJ Backs OpenAI In Legal Face Off With New York Tim...
YahooTrump administration backs OpenAI in NYT copyright lawsuit
QuartzTrump administration backs OpenAI in NYT copyright lawsuit
Business StandardUS government backs OpenAI in New York Times', others' copyr...
NewsMaxTrump Admin Backs OpenAI in Copyright Battle
FirstpostUS Government Backs OpenAI in Copyright Fight With New York ...
TechCrunchU.S. government sides with OpenAI on issue of training LLMs ...
RTE.ieUS government backs OpenAI in NY Times copyright case
Washington PostDOJ urges judge to rule for OpenAI, Microsoft in N.Y. Times ...
BetaNewsTrump admin backs OpenAI in NYT copyright fight
Crypto BriefingTrump administration supports OpenAI in NYT copyright lawsui...
The VergeThe Trump administration is supporting OpenAI in the NYT cop...
cnbctv18.comUS government backs OpenAI in New York Times copyright case ...
The HillTrump admin backs OpenAI 'fair use' argument in suit from Ne...
TribLIVETrump administration backs OpenAI in New York Times' copyrig...
Yahoo NewsTrump Administration Backs OpenAI in New York Times Copyrigh...
TheWrapTrump Administration Backs OpenAI in New York Times Copyrigh...
www.theepochtimes.comUS Government Backs Artificial Intelligence Company in New Y...
ArcaMaxTrump Justice Department weighs in on OpenAI copyright case,...

A news briefing built to show both sides.

The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.

← Earlier in this briefing
Gaza health ministry says more than 900 killed this year despite ceasefire as Ne...
Gaza's Hamas-run health ministry says more than 900 people have been killed in Israeli attacks in the territory this...
International Affairs
Next in this briefing →
Trump Proposes Renaming Strait of Hormuz the 'Trump Strait'; White House Shares ...
President Donald Trump posted on Truth Social on Wednesday asking whether the Strait of Hormuz should be renamed the...
U.S. Politics

Continue Reading

More in Technology & Society

New York City bars generative AI for public school students through eighth grade for one year

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Schools Chancellor Kamar Samuels announced on Wednesday a one-year moratorium on...

Technology & Society
Related this week

Canada pledges up to C$560 million to Brazilian-led tropical forest fund

Canada pledged up to C$560 million (US$392.5 million) over four years to the Brazilian-led Tropical Forests Forever...

Science & Climate
From this briefing

Oil Trades Near $95 a Barrel After Renewed U.S.-Iran Strikes; Prices Ease Thursday

U.S. forces struck targets along Iran's southern coast and in the Strait of Hormuz starting Aug. 30, the first such...

Business & Markets
Back to all stories

A news briefing built to show both sides.

The day’s biggest stories in one short brief, built to show both sides and the competing values behind the headlines. Free in your inbox.

ReframedNews

A daily news briefing on the day’s top stories, built to show both sides.

Written by AI from news reporting. We review published briefings. Who writes this →

Navigate

Quick ReadArchiveSettings

Company

AboutHow it worksSkylark CreationsSign InTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

© 2026 Reframed.News

Made by Skylark Creations